Login to access exclusive gaming content, win competition prizes
and post on our forums. Don't have an account? Create one now!
Why should you join?
Click here for full benefits!
Follow our Twitter feedBethesda buys id Software - we shit you not: http://bit.ly/mNZ03
SIGN IN/JOIN UP
GamesForumsCheatsVideo
Transformers videos: Megan Fox fail | Bethesda buys id Software | Hands-on with Battlefield 1943 | 300 exhibitors up for Gamescom | Modern Warfare 2... for mobiles | Original Final Fantasy for PSN | THQ plans global restructure | Microsoft confirms 3DV IP acquisition | World of Warcraft patch upgrades world map | Mass Effect 2 unlockables from iPhone game | Pre-order Assassin's II, get a palace | 360 Avatars get summer wear | Rockstar New England cuts ten percent of staff | More PS3 firmware to not get excited about | Final Fantasy VII does massive damage | First Max Payne 3 shots | Uncharted 2 is E3 Best Of Show | Monster Hunter Freedom Unite video | MS to sell extortionate Lips mics | Tekken 6 dated, video | EA: Natal, Sony motion control a "huge opportunity" | Castle Crashers gets a million players | PC-exclusive Tropico 3 bound for 360 | Bust-A-Move Live headed for XBLA | Madden NFL 10 Wii video & shots
All|PC|PlayStation|Xbox|Nintendo|Download PC Games
Search CVG
Computer And Video Games - The latest gaming news, reviews, previews & movies
CVG Home » Reviews
PreviousPikmin 2: New Play Control! WIILittle King's Story WIINext

Chronicles of Riddick: Assault on Dark Athena

No place to hide
Chronicles of Riddick: Assault on Dark Athena should've been released a year ago. Originally starting life as a small expansion to Xbox's Escape from Butcher Bay, it's now a full-length, eight-hour sequel to the critically acclaimed shooter.

Kicking off where the first game finished, 'Athena sees our man Riddick caught by a massive, Borg-like mercenary ship that's capturing humans and turning them into horrific, mechanised zombie drones. Naturally, angry Vin Diesel's out to chin the bad bosses at the helm, and look absolutely as hard as he can while he does it.

Exactly as we expected from the blokes behind The Darkness, the presentation in 'Athena is impressive; scripted scenes between Riddick's various shady characters, though not quite up there with Metal Gear Solid, look fantastic.

Starbreeze's upgraded facial animation tech provides some truly emotional scenes between the inhabitants of the ship, while the universe itself is as gritty and believable as sci-fi gets.

Chronicles of RiddickGameplay footage
2:23  Drone control gameplay
Click to playClick to play in HD
Now playingMore videosShare this 

Playing as Riddick is an immersive and satisfying experience. Hand-to-hand combat is a visceral power-mix of knives to the face, snapped necks and getting smacked round the face with a big metal pole. Scaling high rails and climbing ladders switches the game's perspective into third person, justified by the ease of Riddick's platforming sections which successfully merge into the shoot-sneak-climb set-up.

Like Butcher Bay most of the game has Riddick lurking in the shadows, stabbing gun-toting attackers in the back and then turning their weapons on them, before scrambling through air vents. It's one of most satisfying first-person stealth games around.

Riddick's sneaking mechanic is simple; with a press of X you're put into stealth mode and a subtle change of the HUD to the colour blue indicates when you're hidden. With the d-pad you can activate your sinister night vision to see clearly in the dark. It works extremely well and makes for visceral hide and seek killings.

But eventually Riddick gets his hands on some hardware and initially it's a smooth transition from slicing to shooting. Enemy-filled rooms full of shadow (the Dark Athena doesn't have very good lighting) suggest that you're better off darting from the darkness with a blade than a gun. But 'Athena never stops you from going in all guns blazing, which removes a lot of the pressure of having to 'Splinter Cell' every room.

Chronicles of RiddickGameplay footage
2:28  Stealth gameplay video
Click to playClick to play in HD
Now playingMore videosShare this 

For the first half of the game there's no doubt that Assault on Dark Athena is a brilliant and gritty stealth shooter. But for some reason it all goes downhill at about the half way point ... right about where it probably would've ended if it stayed the small expansion it was intended to be.

After a plot 'twist' in place of where the end credits should've been, the emphasis in Riddick quickly switches from sneaking and sabotage to straight-laced first-person shooter drudgery.

For most of the later half of the game you've got a gun in you hands and clever set pieces are swiftly replaced with frustrating mini-boss fights, and stabbing from the shadows with generic physics gun puzzles.

There are no explosive barrels in the game (yay) but in permanent Call of Duty mode Riddick ultimately lacks the flair and inventiveness that made it so brilliant in the first place.

The game doesn't feel designed for big gun battles; with so much of the original game's focus placed on melee combat and 'gun = death', large fire fights become lethal set pieces that drain your health bar in a second. Dark Athena's later section is very difficult, sometimes frustratingly so.

It's sad that an otherwise strong addition to Riddick has to end with a whimper then. But thankfully the excellent Xbox original is still around to take center spotlight - and it stands up today just as well as it did five years ago.

Escape from Butcher Bay is a better game than 'Dark Athena. In structure, narrative - even set pieces - it's the more solid, expertly crafted experience - and now it's sporting hi-def visuals (though not quite as pretty as the new game) and all of AODA's updated controls as well.

Ultimately thanks to a change of plan mid-way through development Assault on Dark Athena isn't as well executed as its older brother - and isn't even that great in the second half.

But the other 50 percent is still brilliant, and coupled with the excellent original game - which definitely needs to be played if you haven't already - tons of unlockables and a multiplayer mode with great potential (read more about that here), Riddick's late shortcomings are redeemed by one of the most solid FPS packages around.

Buy Chronicles of Riddick: Play / Amazon

computerandvideogames.com
// Overview
Verdict
All in, Dark Athena delivers an outstanding FPS bundle for your money.
Uppers
  Presentation
  Visceral and immersive moves
  Butcher Bay is as brilliant as ever
  First-person stealth at its best
Downers
  Second half of 'Athena = no thanks
// Interactive
Share this article:  
Digg.comFacebookGoogle BookmarksN4GGamerblips
del.icio.usRedditSlashdot.orgStumbleUpon
 
Posted by TezChi
Nice review, I already have the game pre ordered and am loving the demo.

I never played Butcher Bay on XBOX 1, so this full remake that features in the game is going be the first thing I play. So I take it I can add another point to the score, for not having played Butcher in the first place?
Posted by Mark Hayhurst
Yep easily. It's awesome
Posted by ledickolas
Yeah 9/10 is fair if you haven't played Butcher Bay. Now's the time.

I'm intrigued by the multiplayer, I'll wait and see what people think of it on here before I dip my toes in.
Posted by Mappman
I had high expectations for this game given the "lost gem" status bestowed upon it by various jounralists and gamers alike.

However I'm sorry to say this, but hasn't anyone else noticed the absolutely dreadful graphics engine, that warps the hell out of the image around the corners, creating a god awful "fish bowl" effect? This completely ruined the demo for me, as I know from past experience that games with this cheapskate approach to 3D always give me motion sickness.

In fact even if it didn't give me motion sickness, it hardly suspends disbelief when the world around you bends as though you were wearing your grandmother's glasses. A great game it may be, but I think I'll leave my stomach where it is thanks.

Disappointing.
Posted by LkS
no pc version? its good that its sh*t then.
Posted by The_KFD_Case
There is going to be a PC version, but unfortunately at latest count it's going to be published with limited activations. So yes, in effect it becomes "crap" thanks to that caveat. :roll:
Posted by Codename21
The "fish bowl" effect was present in the original, to give you a better view whilst in "Stealth Mode" - most likely to enforce the sense of being being Riddick lying in wait to strike, and (even more likely) to help the User play in a stealth-like fashion from the first person.

I'd read somewhere that the collectable Ciggarette Packs have been removed in this version - does anyone know if this is correct?
Posted by falloutwarchief
Nope, the cigarette packs are still in there. I've got the PS3 version and there's a trophy for collecting them and everything.
Read all 8 commentsPost a Comment
// Related Content
Reviews:
Interviews:
News:
More Related
// The Best ofCVG
News | Reviews | Previews | Features | Interviews | Cheats | Hardware | Forums | Competitions | Blogs
Top Games: Tomb Raider: Underworld | Metal Gear Solid 4 | Grand Theft Auto IV | Grand Theft Auto IV | Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare | LittleBigPlanet
Burnout Paradise | Unreal Tournament III | Halo 3 | Xbox 360 Elite | Bioshock
Top Reviews: Overlord Dark Legend | Virtua Tennis 2009 | Ghostbusters | ArmA 2 | Indiana Jones and the Staff of Kings | Sacred 2: Fallen Angel
Prototype | Star Ocean: The Last Hope | Red Faction Guerrilla | The Sims 3 | FUEL
Copyright 2006 - 2009 Future Publishing Limited,
Beauford Court, 30 Monmouth Street, Bath, UK BA1 2BW
England and Wales company registration number 2008885