|
Well, I bet you're asking, what are the formative books that have shaped my life? Read on...
Animal Liberation by Peter Singer What a book! I'm not exactly sure what possessed me to pick it up, but I'd heard it was something of a classic for the Animal Rights movement. It begins by a philosophical explanation of why we accord rights to individuals, and concludes that this is based not on any intrinsic qualities based on the possession of a soul or a high intellect, but simply that of any sentient being -- the ability to feel pain. This must be the case, because any other distinction leads to contradictions as to special-case humans (for instance, the mentally handicapped) who would not otherwise receive better treatment than higher animals. If you accept this premise, then you have little choice but to extend compassionate treatment to at least the most advanced animals, and disqualify any scientific experiment that we would not be prepared to subject humans to. The book proceeds to discuss the appalling treatment that animals have to endure in both the laboratory and the factory farm. It argues that animal experimentation is largely pointless -- re-running experiments to prove points that have already been well-established, or work that is so abstract as to have no practical benefits. Often when you talk to animal lovers, it's clear they're just simply dotty about cats and dogs -- they only want to save the cute ones. Peter Singer is logically consistent enough to bypass that argument, even professing not to particularly like animals at all! So am I a vegetarian? Umm, no. But it's only because I'm weak-willed and lack integrity, not because I'm unconvinced of the arguments. I find the whole subject of animal rights a very difficult one to bring up, even amongst people used to discussing philosophy; there's an attitude of "Don't want to think about it!" that's common when it comes to changing your diet. The Blank Slate by Steven Pinker
Steven Pinker is something of a pinup hero for me, so I tend to read his books with the fervour and unquestioning attitude usually reserved for religious texts. But, I can't help it -- he's just too damn good! Everything he writes is scholarly, intriguing and decisively argued, and this one is no exception.
The evidence is assembled and produced from various sources -- studies of identical twins reared apart, adopted children compared with natural siblings, anthropological research of different cultures and comparative brain studies. The truth is, biology influences us a lot more than environment and upbringing. I understand why this is hard for some people to agree with, as a former believer in The Blank Slate myself. Where Pinker argues that conservatives have basically got the correct view of human nature and socialists have it wrong, I want to object too; but I can't disagree with the logic.
If you're an avid fan of evolutionary psychology like me, you won't find anything in here that's particularly controversial. But for most people, this book is bound to shake up some deeply held, semi-conscious beliefs.
Story by Robert McKee This recommendation is specifically for all you budding writers out there. If you've ever had any interest at all in screen writing, or just want to understand why some movies fail, this is a great book. It is not, however, a great read, and in fact the best I can say about the writing style is that at least it's transparent. No matter: the essence of a good story is not the dialogue, but the dramatic structure, and this is the book to show you how to create it. The author has his own website at www.mckeestory.com, which is a good place to check out for tips on selling a screenplay, and also gives some info on McKee's screenwriting courses.
The Selfish Gene by Richard Dawkins Whenever I get into those supposed "meaningful" conversations about LUE
(Life, The Universe & Everything), this is the first book I bring up to dazzle people with
my erudition. As I'm usually drunk when I try and explain it I doubt it has the required effect, so
here's a sober attempt to do it justice. The End of History and The Last Man by Francis Fukuyama Hmm. This book was pilloried by the critics when it came out, but I'm
going to stick my neck above the parapet and praise it anyway. I read The End of History as an
idealistic politics undergraduate, and it's had a profound effect on my thinking ever since.
The basic premise is thus: With the collapse of Communism, Liberal Democracy has taken on all-comers
in the ideological world, especially during the turbulent 20th Century
, and emerged triumphant. History as a battle of competing world views is effectively over.
A democratic free market system is quite simply
the most satisfactory way to organize a society's political and economic structures.
Perhaps what put some off the theory was the philosophical baggage that came with it.
Fukuyama attempts to justify his belief with the aid of a particular interpretation of Hegel's
master/slave dialectic (and if you don't know what that is, I won't even begin to explain).
Weaving the Web by Tim Berners-Lee First off, this is not a fully-featured biography of the creator of the World Wide Web;
anyone looking for
the personal story of how One Man Changed the World will be sorely disappointed. Essentially the book
has two parts - how the Web was made, and the author's current job and predictions for the future.
Much of the former revolves around the drafting of technical standards, such as HTML, http and URLs,
and it would be fair to say that here the details are not shyed away from.
What came as a shock to me is the extent of the rivalries in the early days. Tim is too well-mannered
to bitch, but he clearly despises the Netscape founders for attempting to usurp the Web (interesting
to read a story of Microsoft as the Good guys!) Don't agree with what I've said? write in! |