Login to access exclusive gaming content, win competition prizes
and post on our forums. Don't have an account? Create one now!
Why should you join?
Click here for full benefits!
Follow our Twitter feedDSi gets UK launch date: http://tinyurl.com/bfgmhr
SIGN IN/JOIN UP
GamesForumsCheatsOut Now
Major MotorStorm: PR update out now | Blizzard improves StarCraft II visuals | Sonic and the Black Knight movie | UTIII gets huge free DLC expansion | MadWorld dated | Two new Conduit videos | Killzone to match Halo's match-making? | Capcom to reveal Xbox game Feb 23 | Red 360: "nothing to announce," says MS | Ubisoft takes on Wheelman publishing duties | PES 2009 transfer update now live | PS3 firmware 2.7 details leaked? | DSi gets UK launch date | Big Xbox announcements on June 1 | Resident Evil 5 art | 47 Champions Online screens | Eat some more Killzone 2 videos | Shooters dominate Xbox Live | Sony shows off Killzone 2 | Euro DSi date soon | Final Fantasy: Echoes of Time dated | MS to buy motion-sensing tech firm? | Nintendo signs up Smash Bros creator | Street Fighter II HD Remix - PSN tomorrow | Robot handling Halo Wars, AoE DLC
All|PC|PlayStation|Xbox|Nintendo|Games on Demand
Search CVG
Computer And Video Games - The latest gaming news, reviews, previews & movies
CVG Home » Reviews
PreviousRace Pro 360Reviews Index Next

Sega Mega Drive Ultimate Collection

Really the "ultimate" collection?
If you've ever handed over 400 Microsoft points for an Xbox Live Arcade Mega Drive game, it's time to cry. Because for £25 Sega's new packed and polished-as-a-marble-floor Mega Drive Ultimate Collection brings back 40 old school classics. And you're never getting those MS Points back.

First up, because we know the most important selling point of this package is its list of games, here's an, erm, list of games:

  • Alex Kidd
  • Alien Storm
  • Alien Syndrome
  • Altered Beast
  • Altered Beast Arcade
  • Bonanza Bros.
  • Columns
  • Comix Zone
  • Decap Attack
  • Dr. Robotnik's M.B.M.
  • Dynamite Heady
  • E-Swat
  • Ecco 1 and 2
  • Fantasy Zone
  • Fatal Labyrinth
  • Flicky
  • Gain Ground
  • Golden Axe I, III and III
  • Golden Axe Warrior
  • Kid Chameleon
  • Phantasy Star I, II, III and IV
  • Ristar
  • Space Harrier
  • Shining Force I and II
  • Shining in the Darkness
  • Shinobi Arcade and III
  • Sonic I, II and III
  • Sonic and Knuckles
  • Sonic 3D
  • Sonic Spinball
  • Streets of Rage I, II and III
  • Super Thunder Blade
  • Story of Thor
  • Tip Top
  • Vectorman I and II
  • Zaxxon

Not a bad selection, eh? A lot of the titles have stood the test of time rather well and spending an hour or so wrapped up in the nostalgia of Sonic and Knuckles, Streets of Rage or Ristar is all good fun.

While most will turn up for Golden Axe and Sonic, there are plenty of lesser-known retro gems hidden inside. Look out for Treasure's bonkers but brilliant Dynamite Heady, Decap Attack and the criminally underrated Vectorman games.

Sega Mega Drive Ultimate Collection
4:37  Random footage from a few titles




DEBUG - skip to curtain
Click to play
Now playingMore videosShare this 

It's not a bad list at all; there's the odd dated "favourite" we suspect was only included for nostalgia purposes (we're looking at you, Flicky), but most Sega stalwarts would be hard pushed to claim that Sega haven't managed to include a lot of the Mega Drive's best (even if it has snubbed a lot of classics - more on that later).

Emulation on each title, unless we're going to get really picky, is about as spot-on as most will care. Sega kindly provides options for state saves, remapping controls, switching the screen ratio between traditional 4:3 and 16:9 widescreen (although this is visibly stretched) and the weird smoothing option from XBLA ports that makes the game look like its gone skinny dipping in Vaseline.

Hardcore Mega Drive nuts will notice the odd sound anomaly when compared to the original console games (Sonic 3 is most guilty of this), but again it's a very anal point and will go unnoticed by most.

Developer Backbone has done a really great job of creating a well presented and nostalgia-filled package. Menus look sleek and true to the Mega Drive design, while changing your game options on the fly with the back or select buttons is fast and effortless.

There's even an entire museum of trivia, (boring) developer interviews, and box artwork - though the latter's unfortunately only from the North American versions.

Local multiplayer support is also in and a major selling point. Upon unveiling Streets of Rage and Sonic 2 in front of the missus last weekend we discovered the collections' stealth feature; as a retro party game. Playing through Golden Axe III or Streets of Rage with a partner is still fantastic fun and for us provides the real meat of the collection's appeal.

Unfortunately Sega hasn't strengthened this point with online play or leaderboards which are sorely missed, though we appreciate the time and effort that would've been required to get Xbox Live and PSN play up and running.

Achievements (and Trophies), though easy as sin to collect, are nicely spread across titles to encourage you to give each game a go (if you're the type of player tempted by 20G you can earn in five minutes, anyway).

There aren't enough points to stick an Achievement on all 40-odd games, but most have an easy unlockable in the first level (e.g. Sonic's "collect a Chaos Emerald") to tempt you into the game, which potentially could be enough to leave you hooked.

Special mention goes to the three token 'hard' Achievements, such as that awarded for reaching level 11 in Vectorman 2. With the aid of level skip (who knew old issues of CVG would come in handy) it's the easiest 50G we've ever earned.

The problem with Ultimate Collection is, well... it's not quite the "Ultimate" Collection. We could sit here all day and list Mega Drive classics that have no doubt been 'strategically' left out for the inevitable sequel; Outrun, Earthworm Jim, Afterburner, Gunstar Heroes, Toejam and Earl, Space Harrier 2 to name a few.

While we're it at, we're particularly miffed on why Sonic 3 and Knuckles, arguably the best 2D Sonics ever made, which is the result of plugging Sonic 3 into Sonic and Knuckles' special cart, isn't included. The original games are already on the disc!

Insultingly, the 'did you know?' trivia section makes mention of Sonic & Knuckles' old lock-on capability, but the functionality is left out of the collection entirely. Which to us at least, is unforgivable.

Mega Drive Ultimate Collection is a nicely polished bundle with a ton of 16-bit memories. It's by no means the "Ultimate" collection and we hope Sega decides to follow it up with DLC rather than an inevitable full-price sequel.

computerandvideogames.com
// Overview
Verdict
Should be called the "Sega Mega Drive Really Good But Not Quite Ultimate Collection".
Uppers
  Fantastic presentation
  Huge list of games
  Achievements handled well
  Stealth multiplayer hit
Downers
  It's not the ultimate collection
  No Sonic 3 & Knuckles is unforgivable
  Online features next time, please?
// Screenshots
// Interactive
Share this article:  
Digg.comFacebookGoogle BookmarksN4GGamerblips
del.icio.usRedditSlashdot.orgStumbleUpon
 
Posted by KesMonkey
They didn't even include 'Revenge of Shinobi'. I'd love to have the Shinobi collection and the arcade originals of Yu Suzuki's games on my hard drive. I'd even pay 400 points for each of them. But this compilation is certainly not 'ultimate'. No online play, no leaderboards, missing classics, and having to put the disc in the drive for a quick blast of Sonic? No thanks Sega. You've disappointed me yet again.
Posted by svd_grasshopper
sounds bad.

crude stretching and smoothing over. no thanks. stop milking these games once and for all!!

get a proper HD reworking, or full blown sequels to sonic (2.5D like SF4) and streets of rage. a new shinobi wouldnt go a miss either, and probably would be the most interesting sequel.
Posted by Speciala
Why are people paying for this?

Only and idiot would pay for these games.

You will play each one for a few minutes then go back to playing todays, better games
Posted by svd_grasshopper
haha quite true.

you probably wouldnt even play half of them at all.
Posted by joemikey
Yeah, especially when you can download half of these games for free from the internet.

Man, they didn't even include Lion King!

Great shame.
Posted by Crow555
I'd rather they did a Saturn collection or a dreamcast selection than old Megadrive games. I'm tempted to get this but there's so much else out there to play at the moment.
Posted by casperthedog
Been looking forward to this since it was announced, for £25 for me is good value. I recently had to sell many old systems with many of these games and to have them all on one disk for me is a good thing.
Posted by creamerybutter
Newer ≠ Better.
Posted by Picnic12
Aladdin
Alien 3
Another World
Castle of Illusion
Chuck Rock
Gods
James Pond II: Robocod
Lemmings
Puggsy
Quackshot
Virtua Racing
Wiz n Liz
World of Illusion

None of these games? They're really pushing it with the 'Ultimate' description (in fact it's a lie as far as my tastes are concerned) although, to many Xbox 360 and PS3 owners, I suspect that the loss of some of the platform games won't matter too much to them.
Posted by eltonbird
Was it my imagination or did the Original advert for this clearly show the Virtua Racing logo? I'm sure they've changed it?!

The lack of online play is a bit pants though, considering the Sega Classics releases on XBLA do have online play. I'll stick with my SoR2 and Golden Axe on there I think!
Posted by lonewolf2002
The same old titles on a mega drive compilation about time they did release some of the games the reviewer and other posters have mentioned. Stop keep charging people for the same old titles again and again and release a different compilation for once.

I like the idea of the saturn/DC compilation as mentioned above.
Posted by roger4000
what!!!! no revenge of shinobi!!! what i dont get is i had a dvd full of megadrive games (which you can get off the net for free now)
http://www.romnation.net

a few years back with at least 100 games on. blue ray disc anybody? how many gig anybody? i just downloaded zaxxon to see how big it was (and i never realised it was released for the megadrive) and it's 842kb. 3 second download, emu loaded and off I go. i think they could fit the entire catalogue on one disk. or are they preparing the suckers for ULTIMATE MEGADRIVE COLLECTION 2 :wink:
Posted by discostoo
I personally can't wait for the Ultimate Mega Drive Collection 2, with all the best games that they left out of this 'ultimate' collection. Maybe they should look up the meaning of the word?
Posted by rockstarsean
My pick wouyld be Desert Storm, Zombies ate my neighbors, Ghostbusters, Brian Lara Cricket, Fifa '95...
Posted by blynk
Wow, no Sonic 3 & Knuckles? What were they thinking?

Aladin
Castle of Illusion
S3&K

All must have titles. They should be dissapointed with themselves. I know releasing a sequel will get them more cash, but im sure more people would have bought this initial edition if they had just included every Mega Drive game ever on it.
Posted by ginsin
All you do is nothing but complain. Don't you ever get tired?

It's a good collection if a parent has a kid who owns a 360 or PS3, because most of these games are still more than playable. Heck, I may even pick it up at some point when it's really cheap.
Posted by davidc
neat idea....but it needs to be £20 tops and...where's the shooters - Thunderforce, Battle Squadron, Midnight Resistance etc

and streetfighter2 and mortal kombat.....tut tut
Posted by Tricky_Rich
I know it's not technically megadrive, but yet again Sega miss an opportunity to include Sonic CD, arguably the best Sonic game of all time.

Let's face, it no-one's going to release an ultimate mega CD compilation, (because most of the games sucked), so why not put Sonic CD out in a collection like this?
Posted by svd_grasshopper
the games get boring after a few minutes. dont kid yourselves.

its like saying an old banger metro is great because you once owned one.
Posted by eltonbird
Good call mate! I'm glad I'm not the only Battle Squadron fan out there! The Amiga Version was just a smidge better simply for Audio reasons, but it's one of the most satisfying feeling shooters ever made. Would love to see a next gen remake of that!

What some poeple are failing to see though, is that this is a collection of Sega Published titles only, so Desert Strike, Fifa 95 etc. are not going to get in.

Revenge of Shinobi, Castle of Illusion, Shadow Dancer, AfterBurner 2, ThunderForce(III & IV) and Gunstar Heros are tragic omissions though.
Posted by orochiguyver
Downers
It's not the ultimate collection
No Sonic 3 & Knuckles is unforgivable
Online features next time, please?

Your list states Sonic 3 and Sonic and Knuckles is in there...?

No Outrun = no good.
Read all 21 commentsPost a Comment
// Screenshots
PreviousNext1 / 12 Screenshots
// Popular Now
// Related Content
Reviews:
News:
More Related
News | Reviews | Previews | Features | Interviews | Cheats | Hardware | Forums | Competitions | Blogs
Top Games: Tomb Raider: Underworld | Metal Gear Solid 4 | Grand Theft Auto IV | Grand Theft Auto IV | Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare | LittleBigPlanet
Burnout Paradise | Unreal Tournament III | Halo 3 | Xbox 360 Elite | Bioshock
Top Reviews: Sega Mega Drive Ultimate Collection | Race Pro | GTA IV: The Lost and Damned | Street Fighter IV | Bomberman II | Destroy all Humans: Path of the Furon
F.E.A.R 2: Project Origin | Deadly Creatures | Rise of the Argonauts | Burnout: Paradise | Chrono Trigger
GamesRadar Network UK: GamesRadar | CVG | Edge | OXM | ONM
PSM3 | PSW | PC Gamer | XBW 360 | NGamer | PC Zone