Login to access exclusive gaming content, win competition prizes
and post on our forums. Don't have an account? Create one now!
Why should you join?
Click here for full benefits!
Follow our Twitter feedPenny Arcade on CVG / Killzone comments: http://www.penny-arcade.com/
SIGN IN/JOIN UP
GamesForumsCheatsOut Now
Wii sales falling in Japan | CoD 5 PC patched today | New Transformers game revealed | New Ghostbusters video | Need for Speed Online in testing next month | Blizzard not attending E3 2009 | Free PES '09 download | Follow CVG on Twitter! | CoD: Modern Warfare 2 teased | THQ gets digital | Warner buys Snowblind | THQ to cut 600 staff | Penumbra Collection trailer | 13 Rise of the Argonauts screens | L4D Survival Pack: New mode, campaigns revealed | Bionic Commando finally dated | Sega scoops Winter Olympics | Sega reveals Virtua Tennis 2009 | Bad Company 2 revealed | Hawx dated | First Watchmen: The End is Nigh shots | Free Radical renamed Crytek UK | EA shares surge in wake of cost cuts | Time Crisis on iPhone - now | MMOs illegal in Australia
All|PC|PlayStation|Xbox|Nintendo|Games on Demand
Search CVG
Computer And Video Games - The latest gaming news, reviews, previews & movies
CVG Home » PC » Features
PreviousGames For Windows Live Reboot 2009 Is The Year... Of The Military Sim  Next

Soundtrack of our lives

Pavel Barter hits the high notes of game composition
When he started mooting the idea of an orchestra playing music from videogames, people thought the veteran composer Tommy Tallarico was off his rocker. It took him three years to convince publishers and developers that he was sane. "Imagine me making a call to Taito in Japan, asking them for the rights for the score of [1983 arcade hit] Elevator Action. "I'd like to play the theme tune to the game at the Hollywood Bowl with the Los Angeles Philharmonic. Hello... hello?'"

Naysayers were forced to eat their hats when Video Games Live (VGL) premiered in 2005 at the Bowl to around 11,000 punters. Since then, the show has toured worldwide, performing music from Final Fantasy, World of Warcraft, BioShock and Beyond Good and Evil, as well as venturing back to the days of Tetris, Space Invaders, and Pong. VGL even hit the US Billboard charts in August, 2008, with an album of string-tastic tunes.

Tallarico, readying himself for a show in Boston as we speak, is chuffed. Having grown up watching his cousin Steven Tyler, lead singer of Aerosmith, on stage, he always dreamt of producing a flashy show. And VGL is that realisation.

"What makes VGL unique is that everything is completely synchronised to video, rock 'n' roll lighting, special effects, a stage show production, and interactive elements with the crowd," he says. "I like to explain it as having all the power and emotion of a symphony orchestra and choir, the energy and excitement of a rock concert, mixed with the cutting-edge visuals, technology, interactivity and fun of videogames."

The composer knows the score, having worked on over 275 titles since 1991 - Unreal Tournament, Lineage and the Test Drive series amongst them - and has seen game compositions transform from staccato bleeps into symphonic raptures. These days, many renowned movie composers work on game soundtracks: from Lord of the Rings composer Howard Shore, to Academy Award winner Bill Conti (who wrote the theme tune for Rocky, and went on to score The Godfather game), and Danny Elfman (who scored LEGO Batman).

While the pay package is alluring, games tend to put music to the fore, rather than hiding it behind dialogue. You might hear John Williams' Indiana Jones score for a combined total of three hours over the course of a year; play World of Warcraft and you probably devour Jason Hayes' work for 30+ hours a week. "There's definitely more freedom with games," says Jason Graves, who wrote the soundtrack for Dead Space. "Part of it is the nurturing, creative aspects of games - also the amount of music that needs to be composed and implemented in such little time. Instead of being restrained to specific timings from a film, I stretch out and simply compose an idea, like combat or exploration, for several minutes at a time. The other biggest difference is the interactive aspect of game scores - an interactive score has more requirements than a traditional, linear film score."

Jack Wall, Tallarico's VGL cohort - who wrote music for Splinter Cell and Mass Effect - keeps the story arc in mind when working, building melodies around a three-act structure. Genre plays a major role in composition - RPGs, for example, are more story-driven than RTSs - while third-party development tools allow composers to wrap their earholes around a game before putting treble clef to paper.

Graves spent two years working on Dead Space. For the adaptive music, he referred to visual walkthroughs and regularly visited the EA offices to play the game so he could score scenes by experiencing the creature encounters and pant-soiling shocks. Graves would compose music for a level and the audio director then fitted it into the game to see how it interacted with the gameplay. When it came to recording, no expense was spared.

"There were two recording sessions for Dead Space. The first was in Seattle with the Northwest Sinfonia: about 65 players total. The second one was at Skywalker Sound with another 65-piece orchestra plus a 20-member choir."

A lot of people think of memorable game composition in console-y terms (Mario, Zelda, Castlevania, Sonic, etc.) but since the turn of the century, PC titles like Hitman, Warcraft and Half-Life have frequently scooped awards.

"I always try to write catchy melodies for my PC games," says Jack Wall, who also composed for Myst. "PCs have less limitations than consoles - they often have multiple hard drives to stream off. In consoles you only have one stream and that can pose problems."
What about the increasing use of licensed music in games? Does that also pose problems, leaving the composer homeless? Wall reckons not, saying it comes down to what works best for a game. Ironically, some musicians say that composers remove them from the equation, due to the prevalent use of sampled scores.

"When it's appropriate to score with a live orchestra, I'm going to do it every time," says Wall. "I need as many tools in my bag as possible to get the best result. For example, 90% of Mass Effect's music was electronic - I used those tools instead of bringing in a bunch of live players, which I usually do on most of my games. Using sampled scores isn't about cutting anybody out, it's about what's right for that game."

Composers still face stuffy attitudes. Even after the cultural expansion of game music, the classical hierarchy still look down on it. The reality is, though, symphonies across the world are dying because they're not connecting with younger generations. You either adapt or perish, and ventures like Video Games Live invigorate the art form.

"When we work with an orchestra for the first time," says Tallarico, "some musicians inevitably page through the music and say "World of Warcraft? Sonic the Hedgehog? What is this?' You see the older generation - the refined guys who have been doing this 30-40 years - looking at it with apprehension. But when they play the music for the first time, they realise it's legitimate. Our inspirations are rooted in classical music: Beethoven, Mozart, Strauss.

"Besides, when Tchaikovsky debuted the 1812 Overture, he had live cannons firing on stage at the appropriate times. These guys were showmen! If he was around today he'd be using fancy lights, laser, video, whatever it takes. If Beethoven was alive today, he'd be a videogame composer. Make no mistake about it."

PC Zone Magazine
// Interactive
Share this article:  
Digg.comFacebookGoogle BookmarksN4GGamerblips
del.icio.usRedditSlashdot.orgStumbleUpon
 
No comments have been posted yet.Post a Comment
// Screenshots
PreviousNext4 / 4 Screenshots
// Popular Now
News | Reviews | Previews | Features | Interviews | Cheats | Hardware | Forums | Competitions | Blogs
Top Games: Unreal Tournament III | Football Manager 2007 | Medieval 2: Total War | Command & Conquer | Ultima Online: Third Dawn | Alone in the Dark: The New Nightmare
Operation Flashpoint | Global Operations | Team Fortress 2 | Commandos 2: Men Of Courage | Return to Castle Wolfenstein
Top Reviews: Burnout: Paradise | Mirror's Edge | LoTR Online: Mines of Moria | Grand Theft Auto IV | World of Warcraft: Wrath of the Lich King | Left 4 Dead
Football Manager 2009 | Call of Duty: World at War | Command & Conquer: Red Alert 3 | Far Cry 2 | The Witcher: Enhanced Edition
GamesRadar Network UK: GamesRadar | CVG | Edge | OXM | ONM
PSM3 | PSW | PC Gamer | XBW 360 | NGamer | PC Zone