Login to access exclusive gaming content, win competition prizes
and post on our forums. Don't have an account? Create one now!
Why should you join?
Click here for full benefits!
GamesForumsCheatsOut Now
GTA Chinatown Wars: New Videos | Sam & Max headed to XBLA | GTA IV DLC sets XBL record | XBL, PSN full of "rampant homophobia" | Rock Band 2 dated for Wii, PS3, PS2 | Join OPM's 24hr gaming marathon | Sony undergoes management shuffle | EA Sports titles get MotionPlus support | Call of Duty still dominating XBL | Planet 51 game unveiled | Call of Juarez 2: First trailer | Ten new Damnation screens | Free CoD: World at War map hits XBL | LotR: Conquest DLC released | Punch Out dated in huge Nintendo update | Lips gets Coldplay, improved scoring | Resistance PSP MP mode detailed, video | Worms Armageddon Decade confirmed | Ninja Blade out April 3 | Universal joins XBL Video Marketplace | Microsoft shares drop to 11-year low | Killzone content bound for LittleBigPlanet | Analyst: iPod Touch to kill off PSP | Prince of Persia DLC delayed | Xbox Live bans "offensive" lesbian
All|PC|PlayStation|Xbox|Nintendo|Games on Demand
Search CVG
Computer And Video Games - The latest gaming news, reviews, previews & movies
CVG Home » News
PreviousAnother dose of Madworld Red Resi 5 360 officially unveiled  Next

Sony, Nintendo, Nokia sued over wireless

Suit claims PSP, DS and mobiles are infringing on patent
Sony, Nintendo and Nokia are currently infringing on patents related to the connectivity of handheld gaming devices, a new complaint says.

A court filing obtained by Edge from February 13 shows that Plano, Tex.-based Wall Wireless LLC is suing Sony, Nintendo, Nokia and related companies including Sony Computer Entertainment America and Nintendo of America for allegedly infringing upon U.S. patent 6,640,086, named "Method and Apparatus for Creating and Distributing Real-Time Interactive Media Content Through Wireless Communication Networks and the Internet."

The patent explains that the invention "pertains ... to methods and systems that allow an operator to distribute messages having aural or visual content that is generated by the operator using handheld apparatuses such as mobile telephones."

Wall Wireless alleges that Sony's PSP, Nintendo's DS, as well as certain real-time online multiplayer games such as Mario Kart and WipeOut Pulse infringe on the patent. The plaintiff also says that Nokia's mobile devices N81, N82, N93 and N95 infringe on the patent, along with the mobile game Reset Generation.

Wall Wireless' namesake, Corbet Wall, filed for the patent in 2001 in Taiwan and the U.S. The U.S. Patent Office issued the patent in 2003.

The complaint said that each defendant received a notice of the patent in question "at least as early as October 2008." Defendants have yet to take a license under the patent, the filing stated.

"Unless a permanent injunction is issued enjoining Defendants from infringing the '086 patent, Wall Wireless will be irreparably harmed," the complaint added.

Aside from a permanent injunction, Wall Wireless is seeking damages, costs, expenses, attorney's fees and pre-judgment and post-judgment interest.

"As a result of Defendants' infringement of the '086 patent, Wall Wireless has suffered monetary damages that are compensable ... by no less than a reasonable royalty," the filing stated.

Article supplied by Edge Online

computerandvideogames.com
// Interactive
Share this article:  
Digg.comFacebookGoogle BookmarksN4GGamerblips
del.icio.usRedditSlashdot.orgStumbleUpon
 
Posted by kimoak
Yaaaaaaaaaaaaaaawwwwn!!!!!!!!
Posted by vyper_shot
Where do these patent hoarders keep coming from?

This sort of thing needs to be stamped out.
Posted by lmimmfn
typical crappy US patents, how can you patent that? may as well be patenting "method for entering motorized vehicle using hinged apparatus"
Posted by jayson_90210
Surely


Is at its most basic Text Messages and I'm sure someone would have patented that before 2001...
Posted by Dajmin
Corbet Wall (2001) should be suing the US Patent Office (2003) for that one, then the winner suing whoever is left standing after that. It's all nonsense.
Posted by AJDarkstar
My thoughts exactly. I'm going to patent "absorbing air into the bloodstream via the lungs", and sue every breathing being in existence.
Posted by leefear1
»Surely


They may agrue that that is text data rather than audio visual.

However I don't see how this is different from Xbox live. My 360 is connected via wireless to my router so surely the only difference is that I can't really play the 360 while holding it. I find it hard to believe that there is a difference just because one is a handheld unit. What about iPhone? Or even Laptops!

I presume this is a software patent which if true makes me real angry. As a software developer myself I completely disagree with software patents.
Posted by leefear1
I also can't find a website for Wall Wireless LLC which suggests that they have no products at all, which in turn suggests that they are just patent trolls.

There should be a law that states that unless you actually have a product in development or for sale then your patent invalidates itself after 12 months. Patents are there to protect innovators not to hinder innovation and progress. There should also be a limit to the time you have to file infringement. The DS has been out for a good few years, they can't say that they have only just noticed it infringes their patent!
Posted by JuiKuen
Why do stupid companies come out with lame s*** like this? And its not like these systems and devices haven't been around long enough already

Stupid f***ing Yanks :roll:
Posted by svensk101
These stories and the companies concerned piss me off more than any ****ing fanboy ranting. Where have these people been; how long have the DS and PSP been out now?? I also don't see how they (the DS and PSP) can have possibly affected these guys business, profits, whatever. It does seem to be part of the 'something for nothing,' compensation- culture of the US, I just hope they and all the other trolls have their respective cases dismissed with prejudice.
Posted by nb_nmare2
Every time a frivolous claim like this is (innevitably) laughed out of court, the claimant should be forced to pay the defendants the same amount of money they were suing for.

*That* would soon stop this crap.
Posted by jarvis66
I think I'm going to deal with this article using my "method and apparatus for the removal of waste material from the body by means of water" patent. I feel it's the best place for it really. Scumbag money grabbers
Posted by quintus
Texas
Posted by jayson_90210
Don't you mean Homebase?
Read all 14 commentsPost a Comment
// Popular Now
// Related Content
News:
More Related
News | Reviews | Previews | Features | Interviews | Cheats | Hardware | Forums | Competitions | Blogs
Top Games: Tomb Raider: Underworld | Metal Gear Solid 4 | Grand Theft Auto IV | Grand Theft Auto IV | Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare | LittleBigPlanet
Burnout Paradise | Unreal Tournament III | Halo 3 | Xbox 360 Elite | Bioshock
Top Reviews: Silent Hill: Homecoming | Dead Rising: Chop Till You Drop | Dragon Quest V: Hand of the Heavenly Bride | Warhammer 40,000: Dawn of War II | Halo Wars | 50 Cent: Blood on the Sand
Sega Mega Drive Ultimate Collection | Race Pro | GTA IV: The Lost and Damned | Street Fighter IV | Bomberman II
Copyright 2006 - 2009 Future Publishing Limited,
Beauford Court, 30 Monmouth Street, Bath, UK BA1 2BW
England and Wales company registration number 2008885