12:22  GMT (-3:00)
Founded in 1876 Saturday, October 13, 2007 Edition Nº 1786
User:
Passw:
 ARGENTINA
  Nation at a Glance
  Political Beat
  Argentina NEWS
  Your View (Letters)
  Faces & Places
  Argentina in Brief
  Argentina info
  Argentina guides
 THE WORLD
  World in Brief
  Latin America
  Commentary
  World News
  Features
 BUSINESS
  Markets
  Business in Brief
  Aviation
  Motoring
  Central Bank Info
  Market Report
  Business News
  Company News
  Mining Monthly
  Farming
 SHIPPING
  Ships
  Port Movement
  Port Directory
  Shipping
 SPORTS
  Sports News
  Sports in Brief
  On TV
 ENTERTAINMENT
  Entertainment News
  Culture & Ents
 HEALTH
  Health news
  Science
 AMUSEMENTS
  Television
  Day By Day
  Theatre
  Cinema
  Community Life
  Crossword
  Bridge
 ON SUNDAY
  Latin America
  Art and Books
  US and UK News
  Feature and Review
  Edit. RoundUp
  Focus
 CLASSIFIEDS
  Categories
  Classifieds Info
 SUPPLEMENTS
   Get Out
   Education
   Leisure & Travel
   World Trade
   Write on!
 EDITORIAL
  Editorial English
  Editorial Spanish
 COLUMNIST
  Columnist News
 PHOTO ALBUM
 ARCHIVE
 
Home   >  Editorial   >  Crime by omission

ENGLISH VERSION

Crime by omission

 
HERALD STAFF


The fatal shooting of the German-born industrialist Helmuth Mielke by two robbers last weekend in a gated community founded by himself should remind us forcefully that the intricacies of a close Chaco election are not a matter of life and death whereas crime all too often is. Mielke’s case is far from isolated — so far into 2007 there have already been more robberies in gated communities than there are weeks in a year, never mind thousands of crimes against less protected citizens. Only last week the famous former tennis-player José Luis Clerc (second only to Guillermo Vilas in Argentine tennis history and 23rd in the all-time world rankings) returned from the US Open to find his home rifled in a gated community also lying north of this capital
Throughout human history security has always been an individual responsibility but a society can only call itself civilized when this responsibility ultimately belongs to the state. Since the scene of the crime (the Chacras del Molino gated community in Capilla del Señor) was Mielke’s own creation, it might be easy enough to argue that, along the lines of the British saying: “An Englishman’s home is his castle,” he did not build his castle strongly enough. All too often, gated communities are just that, a gatehouse, which is a symbol of security rather than the reality — barbed-wire perimeters are not enough, especially in open country, and even security cameras must be backed by a reliable security staff.
Nevertheless, the primary responsibility lies in the state’s failure to see its role as lying beyond winning elections and collecting taxes. This abdication goes beyond mere crime-fighting, which has been sorely neglected. For example, the state has no policy on the eruption of shantytowns near prosperous areas (which are usually to blame collectively for crimes although not all shanty residents or even the majority are at fault) — a conservative approach would be to relocate or restrict these breeding-grounds of crime while a progressive mentality would dictate active low-income housing policies but this government does neither. In an even broader sense, the insufficient security against crime is allied to a lack of security at all levels, whether legal, institutional or even the supposed custodians of law and order, the police — the number of murders in this country and the far higher death toll claimed by traffic accidents should be seen as correlated phenomena. And all of this should be laid at the door of a state whose efficiency in collecting taxes is progressing in an inverse direction to its efficiency in performing its duties.


Go to top Back to editorial





Letters to the editor

JReynolds-Ch

Newsletter

Dr. Di Salvo

Argentina Info

Classifieds

Allytech



 
 

The Post and Courier

Home |  Argentina |  The World |  Business |  Shipping |  Sports |  Entertainment |  Write On |  Health |  Amusements |  On Sunday |  Classifieds |  Supplements Editorial Columnist Photo Album Archive

Subscribe |  Advertising |  About us |  Contact us

© Copyright 2000 - 2007 © S.A. The Buenos Aires Herald Ltd. All rights reserved   Política de Privacidad