By Steven A. Chin
San Francisco Examiner
April 4, 1993
Barely 48 hours after arriving at Quantico, Va. on Feb. 6, 1989,
U.S. Marine Officer Candidate Bruce Yamashita got the first
inkling he might be in for a really rough ride.
"Yama ... Yama ... Ya-ma-shita. What the hell is that?"
yelled one of his drill sergeants during the first roll call
of Marine Corps Officer Candidate School.
The Hawaii-born sansei - a third-generation Japanese
American - dismissed the remark as part of the "controlled
stress" that comes with the territory in the Marine Corps.
Like the glossy recruitment catalog read: " . . . make or
break. Go or no go. It's where you ... and we ... find out
if you've got what it takes to be an officer of Marines."
Yamashita was sure he had what it took. He'd proven himself
a leader before, as student body president and captain of
his high school football team. Now, fresh out of Georgetown
University law school, he was ready to put all his talent
and skills to work serving his country.
In 10 weeks, he told himself, he'd be commissioned a second
lieutenant in one of the world's elite military outfits. He
wanted it bad. Ten years older than most of his fellow
candidates, he had trained all summer and fall in bulky
combat boots under the hot Hawaiian sun, the words of his
recruiter knocking around in his head: "If you want to make
it through OCS, it's all guts, baby."
Funds Being Raised for PBS Documentary on Yamashita
The Honolulu Advertiser
May 6, 2002
Some 10 years in the making, a documentary chronicling Bruce
Yamashita's historic legal battle with the U.S. Marine Corps is nearly
complete.
If all goes well, "A Most Unlikely Hero" will be ready for
broadcast on PBS sometime this fall. What is needed is another $25,000 for
closed captioning and other technical requirements.
While at Officer Candidate School in 1989, Yamashita, originally from
O'ahu, was the target of repeated racial taunts. Two days before
graduation, he and three other minority candidates were dropped from the
program. Among the reasons given for his disenrollment, the Marines cited
Yamashita's low scores in a subjective leadership evaluation.
Yamashita appealed on the grounds that he had been singled out because
of his race. In 1992, his legal team won the right to review OCS records
and was able to find a pattern of discrimination against minority
candidates.
The case was settled in 1993, and Yamashita received a commission as a
second lieutenant a year later.
"The case got a lot of support in the community and from
politicians, and it resulted in some landmark changes at the Marine Corps
level," said Steve Okino of Honolulu, who is spearheading the
project. Okino said valuable lessons "came out of that whole
process."
Okino said the documentary is intended to remind people of those
lessons. He said the issues raised by Yamashita's case are particularly
relevant after the events of 9/11 led to discussions of diminishing civil
liberties.
The project is sponsored by the Matsunaga Charitable Foundation, with
financial and in-kind support from the Hawaii Community Foundation, the
Honolulu Chapter of the Japanese American Citizens League, the Harburg
Foundation and others.
A Web site — www.unlikelyhero.org
— provides further information about the project and a
form for making donations. |
"Yeah, I understand guts," the former star high school
tailback had replied with quiet assurance.
The next morning, after completing the medical exam,
Yamashita, sporting crisp, newly issued cammies - his
camouflage uniform - was jogging out of the red brick Marine
headquarters to join his platoon when he heard his Master
Sergeant, K.M. Runyun, bark: "Nani o shiteiru-omai!
[Hurry up!] What's your name?"
Yamashita responded in Japanese, hoping the sergeant was
just joking with him. But Runyun persisted, continuing to
speak to him in Japanese. Unamused, Yamashita responded - in
English.
"You speak to me in Japanese! " ordered Runyun, who
continued to address Yamashita in Japanese throughout his
training.
Standing in a chow line later that day, Yamashita's 5-foot,
7-inch frame was jolted to attention by the voice of another
sergeant, Leland W. Hatfield, booming behind him.
"Hey, you speak English?" the sergeant bellowed, silencing
the mess hall packed with a fresh class of candidates.
"Yes, Sergeant Instructor," a stunned Yamashita replied.
"Well, we don't want your kind around here," Hatfield said.
"Go back to your own country."
The words knifed through Yamashita. He stood silent for
what seemed an eternity, knowing all eyes of "Charlie"
Company Qsome 150 officer candidates - were upon him.
As his training proceeded, says Yamashita, the only American
of Japanese ancestry in his class, no single day passed when
he wasn't either the butt of an ethnic joke or the target of
racial taunts. In fact, even in this "weeding out" process
famed for its intense razzing of recruits, the race baiting
was conspicuous to many others.
Despite the racial harassment, Yamashita appeared to be
passing all academic and physical tests required of
prospective officers. But only two days before graduation,
Yamashita and four other officer candidates - all but one of
them minorities - were called before the Battalion Review
Board and "disenrolled"Qwashed out of OCS. The board told
Yamashita the reason was "unsatisfactory leadership" -- a
grade based largely on peer evaluations.
Two days later, at an exit interview with Marine captain
Victor Garcia, Yamashita protested his mistreatment, saying
he "did not appreciate all the derogatory racial remarks
that were made to me."
In the ensuing conversation, Yamashita says, Garcia misled
him into thinking such behavior was consistent with Marine
Corps policy. He recalls Garcia arguing, "with a hint of
pride," that he had been subjected to racial insults
himself, called "taco head" and "Taco Bell." "But I made
it," the captain concluded.
Asked to provide specifics of his mistreatment, Yamashita
declined, believing it would be futile. The Marine Corps
later argued that Yamashita's failure to provide a written
account of his harassment "prevented OCS from doing a timely
investigation."
His dream of becoming the first U.S. military officer in
his family dashed, a confused and shaken Yamashita returned
to Honolulu.
The 36-year-old Yamashita, who still maintains his OCS-style
crewcut, was prepared to accept harsh treatment. But nothing
in his experience prepared him for the racist abuse his
officers heaped on him.
"I can run faster, do better in academics, clean my rifle
better," he says. "I can press my cammies better. But I
can't change my ethnicity."
Yamashita, the youngest of five children, was raised in a
middle-class community of Honolulu called St. Louis
Heights. The racially diverse climate of Hawaii in the 1960s
and '70s, where his friends, teachers and coaches were of
many ethnicities, was a world apart from Quantico.
His Samoan football coach came from one of the poorest parts
of town, yet regularly invited his players over for lunch at
his mother's house.
In Hawaii, such slang terms as Portagee (Portuguese),
Buddhahead (Japanese), Haole (white), Yobo (Korean) and Pake
(Chinese), used in a vernacular context, do not carry the
heavy pejorative connotations of stateside slurs, he adds.
"You grew up with all kinds of people," he says. "When
you're living in that kind of community and you make jokes
about other ethnicities, they seem less harmful."
Officer Candidate School was Yamashita's wake-up call to
racism, mainland style. "I had never encountered anything
like that in my life," he says. "What made it even worse
was that you're in that environment where you want to blend
in. You want to be an American."
On his occasional Sunday off at Quantico, Yamashita recalls,
he would call home and tell his parents OCS was a
"nightmare," but never mention the racial harassment.
"It would have broken their hearts," he says quietly. "Their
whole lives were spent fighting this stuff. Being second-
generation Japanese Americans - fighting the war, the fact
that they rarely spoke Japanese, always English, the fact
that they always buy Chevrolets, never Japanese cars, their
education.
"Their generation was about assimilation to a large extent,"
says Yamashita. "And they did it kodomo no tame-ni, for
the sake of the children."
Yamashita's 71-year-old mother, Pearl, is an associate
professor at the University of Hawaii's College of
Education; his father, Paul, 81, is a retired bridge
engineer for the state. Like many nisei - second generation
Japanese Americans Q Yamashita's parents never forgot the
discrimination they endured following the Japanese military
attack on Pearl Harbor in 1941. Though sheer numbers
prevented the mass internment that occurred on the West
Coast, the Japanese in Hawaii came under intense scrutiny.
Community religious and civic leaders were rounded up and
shipped to mainland internment camps. Japanese-language
schools were shut down. Nisei were dismissed from their
posts in the Hawaiian National Guard and barred *om joining
the armed services.
As the war intensified, the nisei were belatedly permitted
to form combat units. More than 10,000 volunteered,
creating the all-Japanese American 100th Battalion and 442nd
Regimental Combat Team. Sent to the European front, the
442nd became the most decorated fighting unit in U.S.
history.
Yamashita's uncle Daniel served with the 442nd in Italy. In
1944, he was wounded while fighting German troops in the
Battle of the Arno River and received a Purple Heart for his
bravery.
"As far as I'm concerned, the price has been paid by my
grandparents and my parents," says Yamashita. "For me to go
to this school and be told 'You're less of an American' or
'You don't belong here' is b.s."
Before OCS, Yamashita spent four years as a young expatriate
in Japan. After graduating from the University of Hawaii in
1980, he headed to Tokyo determined to become proficient at
speaking Japanese and "become more international."
He took a job editing English correspondence for a small
trading company, living as a sarariman (Japanese salaryman),
rising at 6 a.m. six days a week and commuting two hours
into Tokyo by train. He shared a dormitory room with the
company's 55year-old manager, Tadashi Iwata, his guardian
and mentor. In return, Yamashita cooked meals, bought beer
and performed assorted household chores for him. "I was his
slave," recalls Yamashita. But "he was looking out for me,
going to bat for me. He was like my dad."
Mastering Japanese was one thing; learning the subtle nuances
of Japanese culture proved another matter. "I was making
cultural mistakes left and right," says Yamashita. "It was a
nightmare."
He remembers initially greeting the 70-year-old president of
his company with a big American "Hi! How are you?" -- making
sure to establish good eye contact.
"He was very offended by that and people let me know,"
Yamashita recalls. "Iwata-san took me aside and said, 'All
you're expected to do is bow. And don't look at his eyes;
keep looking down."'
Another faux pas was leaving his ohashi (chopsticks)
sticking up in his bowl of rice or soba. "That's like
death," he explained. "They do that at funerals. I never
knew that."
After a year, Yamashita quit the company and started
Yokomeshi Shimbun, a newspaper geared to students of
Japanese. Written in simple kanji (characters) by
foreigners like Yamashita, the articles ranged from
interviews with Akebono, Japan's Hawaii-born champion sumo
wrestler, to investigative pieces on Sunya, a Tokyo ghetto.
The paper was a hit, particularly among Japanese who wanted
to know what foreigners thought of Japan.
"I saw myself as an ambassador," says Yamashita. "Japanese
saw me as an American and would ask me about America. So you
try to put on a good face and try to bridge the gap."
In 1984, Yamashita returned to the States to study law and
international relations at Georgetown University. During his
final year there, several friends at the School of Foreign
Service urged him to join the military. On a Christmas
break, Yamashita returned to Honolulu and, on the
recommendation of a Marine recruiter, called up Maj. Ernie
Kimoto.
Kimoto, then a lawyer based at Fleet Marine Force Pacific-
Camp Smith in Oahu, was winding up a distinguished 20 years
of service that included commanding a 240Marine combat unit
in Vietnam in 1969 and serving as senior staff Judge Advocate
at Camp Butler in Okinawa in the early '80s.
Over lunch, the two talked Marines. Kimoto liked what he
saw - "a homeboy interested in serving his country." Beyond
that, he saw a bright, mature man about to earn degrees in
law and international relations - certainly a change from
recent college grads Kimoto was accustomed to counseling.
"Bruce was unusual. He wanted something different,"
recalls Kimoto, 47, now a staff lawyer in the Hawaii
attorney general's office. Yamashita had been high school
student body president and captain of his varsity baseball
and football teams. He also was elected to serve as a
delegate at the state's Constitutional Convention.
And another Asian officer surely couldn't hurt Marine
statistics, according to Kimoto, who counted only 20 Asian
active duty officers in the Marines' 1988 bluebook. "I was
looking at this as a new frontier for Bruce," says Kimoto.
By graduation, Yamashita's mind was made up. He turned down
the Army JAGQ Judicial Advocate General, because it "was
just a two-week orientation before you're shipped out." With
the help of Hawaii Sen. Daniel Inouye, he secured a special
age waiver to enter the 140th Class at Officers Candidate
School. At 32, he was 10 years older than most recruits.
"Maybe it's this macho football part of me, but I wanted to
earn my stripes," said Yamashita. "Most people might just go
the fastest route, but I found the Marine Corps challenge
very attractive."
Kimoto was shocked when, nine months later, he got a phone
call from Yamashita.
"As he described his experience, my feelings evolved into
real anger and disgust," recalls Kimoto, who had just
retired from the Marines. "I was surprised that the Marine
Corps in this day and age could do such a thing. I'm proud
of being a Marine, but the way they treated Bruce is
inexcusable."
Kimoto believes that Yamashita's commanding officer lost
control of his subordinates. "Once the sergeants realized
they could get away with the harassment, it grew," he says.
"It's insidious. They began a campaign of slurs. If the
leaders of the platoon don't think a candidate is going to
make it, the message is passed on to the others."
Yamashita didn't consider protesting his treatment during
training. "You're not thinking about your civil rights and
fairness ," he says . "You're just trying to survive ."
He says he never knew when a sergeant might shout him down,
ridicule him for his Japanese heritage or flag him with an
"unsatisfactory evaluation," the equivalent of a high school
demerit. He ended up with a platoon-high 32 "unsat evals,"
ranging from deficiencies in military basics, such as an
untidy uniform, to an integrity violation, which he claims
was trumped-up.
On the P-T (physical training) field the first week, one
sergeant tagged him with the name "Kawasaki-Yamaha-
Yamashita" rather than addressing him as "Candidate"
Yamashita. The Marines later claimed the sergeant was
dyslexic. Another sergeant called him "Kamikaze Man."
In Yamashita's third week, a sergeant, Melvin Brice, turned
to him while lecturing the platoon in the squad bay, their
barracks.
"Eh Yamashitee, were Japan and Russia ever at war during
World War II?," Brice asked.
"I think they were, sergeant instructor," Yamashita replied.
"No way. You know why, Yamashitee?" said the sergeant, nose
to nose with the recruit. "Because we kicked your Japanese
ass. That's why."
That was far from the end of it. On several other occasions,
he recalls another sergeant, E.F. Carabine, yelling,
"Yamashita, quit bowing . . . This is America, man."
In his sixth week, Sgt. Runyun approached Yamashita while he
was waiting in line for lunch. "Sorry, Yamashita," he said,
"but we have no tea or sushi here." It was one of the few
times Runyun spoke to him in English.
The same week, a fellow officer candidate, Edward O'Brien,
approached Yamashita, who was cleaning his rifle, to ask:
army?"
"Because, O'Brien, I'm an American," Yamashita found himself
explaining.
Later, recalls Yamashita, "I thought, to this guy that I'm
an American - this is not good."'
Until OCS, "the fact that I was bicultural, bilingual was a
real positive," he says. people. It goes back to
competitiveness. This is what America needs."
But at OCS, "I experienced the backlash," he says. "It can
make dreams not come true."
In the three months after his discharge, Yamashita struggled
with self-doubt and humiliation. He resumed his law career,
passing the bar and going into private practice as a
criminal defense attorney. The Corps' rejection hurt him
deep inside, but he didn't challenge it.
Then, one day, Al Goshi, a friend who was a West Point
graduate, told Yamashita that racial remarks were strictly
forbidden at Army OCS. Acquaintances and friends who were
officers in the Army, Navy and Marines said much the same
thing.
Spurred on by their outrage, Yamashita decided to act. In
January 1990, he sent a letter to Corps Commandant General
Alfred M. Gray protesting the racist treatment he had
received at Quantico . "It tainted the way I was viewed and
evaluated by the staff and fellow candidates and thereby
prevented fair judgement of my leadership ability," he
wrote.
A preliminary inquiry concluded the Corps was not guilty of
racial discrimination. In a response to an inquiry on
Yamashita's behalf from Sen. Inouye, the sole Asian American
in the U.S. Senate, Gray wrote that "Mr. Yamashita is
looking for reasons outside of himself to fault . . . "
But Yamahita kept up his fight. In October 1990, he filed
appeals with the Navy Discharge Review Board and the Naval
Board for the Correction of Naval Records, charging that the
persistent racial harassment by his superiors resulted in
his poor leadership scores. The Marine Corps, which falls
under the jurisdiction of the U.S. Navy, reopened its
investigation.
Finally, Yamashita began to get vindication. A lO-month
probe by the Navy's Inspector General verified most of the
egregious incidents. There were "some rather crude remarks
made based on his ethnicity," said Chief Warrant Officer
William Wright, a Marine Corps spokesman. "It was determined
that they were uncalled for and the commandant of the Marine
Corps issued a formal apology."
"There are often times in training when high stress is
acceptable," Wright added. "However, to use one's gender,
to use one's racial background or ethnic background, is
unacceptable. The Marine Corps will simply not tolerate it."
Along with the apology, the Marine Corps offered Yamashita
the chance to retake the officers' course. He refused,
saying he had all but completed the program the first time.
Seeking to clear his record and be reinstated as an OCS
graduate, Yamashita pressed on with his appeal, finally
getting a hearing before the Discharge Review Board in
November 1992.
There was "a tacit agreement
among the officers and the drill instructors," said Clayton
Ikei, Yamashita's attorney. "The drill instructors would
harass and the officers would permit it."
The board, however, ruled that it lacked the authority to
determine if racism was critical to Yamashita's
disenrollment. That decision is pending before the Asst.
Secretary of Navy for Manpower and Reserve Affairs, who can
either accept the Review Board's interpretation or request a
new hearing.
Another appeal is pending before the Board for the
Correction of Naval Records. While Yamashita is not hopeful
about this appeal, he must exhaust the administrative review
process before he can sue the Marine Corps in U.S. Claims
Court for reinstatement and back pay.
The circuitous path, explained Ikei, is based on a U.S.
Supreme Court case (Chappell vs. Wallace, 1983) involving
five black sailors who filed suit in U.S. District Court in
San Diego claiming they were discriminated against by
superior officers. The Supreme Court said that because the
military has administrative procedures to address such
claims, military personnel were exempt from the procedural
safeguards a civilian has under the Title VII Civil Rights
Act.
But Ikei, who has handled discrimination cases for 20 years,
argues that the military administrative process is
ineffective and badly in need of re-examination.
"If Bruce had been a civilian, under the present law he
would be entitled to reinstatement, back pay, compensatory
damages and punitive damages," as well as a jury trial, Ikei
says.
Yamashita's struggle, covered extensively by the Hawaiian
news media, has struck a powerful chord among the islands'
politicians and Asian American groups. In April 1991, the
Hawaiian legislature sent Congress a resolution demanding
his reinstatement, punishment of offending Marine sergeants
and other remedies. Sen. Inouye is also continuing to
pursue the matter. In October 1992, a statutory amendment
written by Inouye was passed by Congress requiring the
Defense Department's military schools to certify in that
"appropriate measures have been taken to publish and enforce
regulations" prohibiting racial discrimination.
The National Pacific Asian Bar Association also decided to
back Yamashita after its former president, ex-Marine Hoyt
Zia, learned of the case.
"It was like deja vu," recalls Zia, who has since moved
from San Francisco to Honolulu. pretty much what happened
to me at Officers Candidate School in 1975 - that same sort
of racism and insensitivity to Asian American issues."
"My nickname was Candidate Kung Fu," says Zia, who served
his 31/2 years at the 155 Battery in Okinawa, and 29 Palms
in Southern California.
Zia's platoon commander, however, overheard the slurs and
made the offending sergeant "stop it and apologize."
Nevertheless, Zia noted that most Marines teaching at OCS
had recently returned from Vietnam and routinely referred to
the Chinese, Vietnamese or Japanese as "Chinks, or gooks, or
Japs, or Nips or slants." One instructor opened a class with
this memorable ditty: 'We wonder where the yellow went, when
we dropped napalm on the Orient."
In the high-stress, survival-of-the fittest environment of
OCS, attacks on ethnicity amounts to an unfair disadvantage,
explains Zia. "Let's say the amount of stress the Marine
Corps is allowed to put on people is the equivalent of a
60pound pack. If you throw in race - as in Bruce's case - it
adds another 10 pounds to the pack. He's got a heavier
burden to shoulder."
Yamashita says the harassment was most harmful during peer
evaluations, which were the basis of his leadership grade.
Every three weeks, candidates in each squad were asked to
rank and critique their peers. The criteria: With whom would
you most want to go into combat?
"Because Bruce was taunted more, lectured to more by the
sergeant instructors, it was going to affect his peer
ratings. There's no doubt about that," says Ron Catipon, a
Filipino American in Yamashita's platoon who was also
disenrolled from the course.
"They tell you to conform," says Catipon, who testified for
Yamashita at the November Review Board hearing. "Everybody
is supposed to wear the canteen on the same side, store gear
the same way. You're suppose to blend in as a group thumb,
it can affect the way you look at them."
Catipon recalled an incident he says typified Yamashita's
treatment. The platoon was lined up at attention in the
squad bay receiving a lecture by Staff Sergeant Brice.
"Bruce and I were standing at the front. In the middle of
the lecture, he turns to Bruce and asks him point-blank: 'Do
you know who Ultra Man (a Japanese cartoon character) is?'
It was completely off subject and it took Bruce by surprise.
I think he said, 'No, sergeant instructor . . ."'
"At that point, the sergeant instructor just continued as if
he had never asked the question. When you're at attention,
you're not supposed to break rank, but everyone was
laughing," says Catipon, adding that the recruits weren't
disciplined for the violation.
For his part, Sen. Inouye has a powerful personal reason for
refusing to let the matter die. Call it a blood debt.
"My brothers in the 442nd Regimental Infantry Combat team
fought and died with the conviction that spilling our blood
would improve the way of life for future generations,"
Inouye said recently. "I could not, and would not, let their
sacrifice be for naught."
At a time when the Pentagon is contending with a number of
hotly contested issues, including whether gays should be
allowed to serve in the military and the sexual abuses that
came out in the Tailhook scandal, Yamashita's case raises
the specter of institutional racism - not only against Asian
Americans but also African Americans and Latinos.
Despite a 1948 federal law desegregating the military,
minorities remain grossly underrepresented at officer
levels. African Americans, Hispanics and other minorities
currently make up 10 percent of Marine Corps officers, while
filling 31 percent of enlisted ranks. Asian Americans and
Pacific Islanders make up just 1.2 percent of Marine
officers and 1. 5 percent of the enlisted, although they are
2 .9 percent of the overall U.S. population.
The Japanese American Citizen's League has stoutly supported
Yamashita in his struggle, providing moral support,
publicity, and legal counsel by Honolulu attorney Ikei. In
conjunction with Yamashita's case, it also commissioned a
study of the Marines"'disenrollment" patterns. Between 1982
and 1990, the JACL study found, minority candidates in the
Officer Candidate School course were "disenrolled" at a rate
of 41 percent, as opposed to 34 percent for white
candidates. In Yamashita's class, the 140th OCS, 60 percent
of the minority candidates were "washed out," in contrast to
28 percent of whites.
The Marine Corp has admitted "there are some big differences
between disenrollment of white candidates and non-white
candidates," says Marine spokesman Wright.
At his Nov. 19,1992, Review Board hearing, Yamashita
presented the study's findings, indicating that between 1982
and 1990, the Marine Corps Officer Candidate Schools
demonstrated a "pervasive, persistent pattern of
discrimination against minority officers candidates."
Col. William Reinke, Yamashita's commanding officer, had the
worst record among the four officers who headed OCS during
the eight-year period, according to the study. For the five
classes under Reinke, minority disenrollment was 17 percent
higher than for whites.
The statistics, provided by the Marine Corps under the
Freedom of Information Act, "destroy any pretense about Mr.
Yamashita receiving fair and equal treatment in OCS," said
Honolulu JACL President William Kaneko. "The data show that
there was statistically little or no chance for Bruce to be
commissioned because the system was stacked against him and
every other minority candidate for almost a decade."
Marine Corps Commandant Gen. Carl E. Mundy Jr. has since
formed a panel to examine the role of race in officer
recruitment and attrition at OCS. The panel's report is
expected this month. "The Quality Management Board will not
deny that Mr. Yamashita's case had something to do with its
creation," says Marine spokesman Wright.
Back at Quantico, the sun had already set when Yamashita
finally left the Battalion Review Board after being
discharged and made his way back to the squad bay.
He dragged his exhausted body across a set of railroad
tracks. Dejected and confused, with tears welling up in his
eyes, Yamashita paused to sit on the curb facing the red
brick headquarters . It was one of the few solitary moments
he'd had during the grueling 10 weeks.
Back in the squad bay, one of the sergeants, upon learning
of Yamashita's disenrollment, ordered the platoon to line up
in formation and give Yamashita an "Urah! ," the Marine
cheer of solidarity.
"That's when I broke down," Yamashita says. "I got from
those three 'Urahs' what I had expected officially from the
Marine Corps. It was a tremendous feeling of satisfaction
that someone realized that this guy had taken a lot of s*** --and
never quit. Maybe, in a roundabout way, it was an
acknowledgement of the injustice."