In downtown Memphis, two public parks have long been
fixtures of the city, places that people of all races have
come to know and accept as a part of the landscape.
But there is now a move afoot to remove the names of
Jefferson Davis and Nathan Bedford Forrest, president of the
Confederacy and a founding father of the Ku Klux Klan,
respectively, from the parks, even though there appears to be
a great amount of division amongst black Memphians on whether
or not a name change is necessary.
Saturday, a rally will be held not far from the parks to
push city officials to move the names of men associated with
racist acts of the past. Rev. Al Sharpton will headline the
rally in hopes of getting more people on board, Judge D’Army
Bailey, a Shelby County Circuit Court judge, told
BlackAmericaWeb.com.
“There have been thousands of blacks who’ve signed
petitions asking (City Council) to rename the park. Rev.
Sharpton looked at this as a battle in Memphis,” Bailey said.
“He believes it’s a very significant national battle and one
that needs to be won.”
Blacks make up approximately more than 60 percent of
Memphis’ 650,100 residents, according to the 2000 U.S. Census.
Bailey said that it’s high time that all black Memphians,
including Mayor Willie W. Herenton, demand that the names of
Davis and Forrest, the KKK’s first Grand Wizard, be removed
from parks that, in essence, add to the beauty of Memphis.
While just names, Bailey said they symbol a time in which
black people were subject to extreme hardships.
“People ask the question, ‘What’s in a name?'” Bailey said.
“But I ask them, why do they ban Nazi symbols and not have any
recognition of Adolph Hitler in Germany? Why did the United
States forces pull down the statue of Saddam Hussein as their
first act against tyranny?
“Names and symbols represent either an allegiance to or
disavowal of something,” Bailey added. “It’s well past the
time to remove allegiance to those whose prime intention was
to erase a whole race of people.”
Bailey, a self-proclaimed activist, believes that blacks
must always speak out against injustice of any kind. While a
student at Southern University in the early 1960s, Bailey was
expelled because of his work with the anti-segregation
movement. It’s a stance he wishes Mayor Herenton would also
take, Bailey said.
“He has said that he has the authority to change the name,
and he does not think it needs to be changed,” Bailey said of
Herenton, a four-term mayor who was elected the city’s first
black mayor in 1991. Bailey maintains that Herenton is fearful
of allowing the city to become engulfed in yet another racial
controversy that may give a black eye to Memphis, still solely
viewed by many as the place where Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr.
was assassinated.
Gale Carson, a spokesperson for Herenton, said the mayor
was unavailable for comment Monday. He did, however, issue a
public statement about the statues’ names in which he alludes
to a rally for renaming the statues as a possible hindrance to
the city’s image.
“It is in the best interest of the City of Memphis that
this issue is addressed carefully and respectfully of diverse
perspectives,” Herenton said last week. “Believe me, I
understand and share the same commitment many citizens have
(against) bigotry and racial hatred, but digging up and moving
graves or renaming city parks is not the proper way of dealing
with this issue. We don’t want to create a spectacle for the
national media.”
Johnnie Turner, executive director of the NAACP’s Memphis
branch, said ever since she was a little girl, black Memphians
have had a problem with the David and Forrest parks. But in
2005, Turner told BlackAmericaWeb.com, there
are bigger issues to address than the name of a public
park.
“Anybody, particularly an African-American, should find the
names reprehensible, but there’s a lot of stuff out there
that’s reprehensible,” Turner said, adding that for as long as
she can remember, some group or another has made it their
business to petition for a name change, to no avail.
While her office is working to stop predatory lending
practices that cause senior citizens to lose their homes, the
poor state of public education or an issue of alleged police
brutality in which a young black man was shot at 22 times by
police, Turner said many find the fight for a name change
important, but not nearly as significant as the day-to-day
problems affecting blacks in Memphis and abroad.
“At this point, we are involved in so many more projects
that are germane to the racism that’s present currently and
working adversely against our people,” Turner said, adding
that although she agrees with Bailey’s “Hitler” analogy, she
believes that there comes a point where people need to move
on.
“Hey, we have no qualms for anybody who wants to take up
that cause. We’re saying, 'Go for it,'” said Turner, who
admits that she still becomes angered when she walks near the
parks and sees the signage.
Still, Turner believes that some battles may be bigger than
others, adding, “If it were a priority of ours, we’d be out
there, too.”
Rev. Dwight Montgomery, pastor of Memphis’ Annesdale
Cherokee Baptist Church, agreed with Turner that the names are
offensive. But like Turner, Montgomery, who is also president
of Memphis’ chapter of the Southern Christian Leadership
Conference, told BlackAmericaWeb.com that
there are certain ways to go about bringing effective
change.
“Not only is the SCLC-Memphis chapter opposed to the
present name of the park, but I am opposed to it too. By the
same token, we have greater and higher priorities of which we
are working on,” Montgomery said, pointing to a fight his
organization is leading to restore the state-sponsored
healthcare of tens of thousands of Tennessee residents.
To quell any potential problems, Montgomery will oversee
the Prayer Summit for Racial Harmony on Thursday, an attempt
to bring people of all faiths and races together to build
solidarity surrounding this issue.
“This is going to be an ecumenical and multi-racial way to
help us come together, pray and work to make sure that
whatever happens in relationship to this park issue, nothing
will get out of hand and no negative things will cause further
polarization,” Montgomery told
BlackAmericaWeb.com.
Both Turner and Montgomery say that the issue has obviously
divided black Memphians. Turner said she also resents the fact
that Sharpton is being brought in to address a local issue.
Calls made to Sharpton’s New York-based National Action
Network were not returned Monday.
With no united front, Turner doubts that much of anything
can be accomplished. Bailey, whose brother, Shelby County
Commissioner Walter Bailey is also involved in the name change
movement, said it’s the message, not the number of people on
board, that will matter most in the end.
“Don’t ask me about the consciousness of my brothers and
sisters,” Bailey said, adding that, historically, too many
blacks tend to be slow in addressing issues of
significance.
“It’s always a small group that sparks a change. That’s
just a part of our historical process,” Bailey said, pointing
to the North Carolina A&T students whose refusal to leave
a Woolworth counter spearheaded a civil rights moment. “But
just like the students in Greensboro, if we get 10 people,
plus Rev. Sharpton, you’ve got the beginning of a revolution
in Memphis.”