Arthurs
Walking in the Sunlight
[Dirigeable; 2002]
Rating: 6.2
It's funny how so many social trends seem to have at least some root in the
politics of elementary school. A scary notion, considering the rationale of any
ne'er-to-do Kindergartner whose top priorities are dictated by "The Pokémon
Trading Card Guidebook." Which brings us to the most obvious reflection of human
fallibility: the desire to be popular. One should note that it's during the
infancy of our formal education when we first become the unassuming targets of
manipulative marketers who would have us believe that their product ensures our
acceptance on the playground (and will, through some magic turn of events, make
Daddy stop yelling at Mommy). Unfortunately, such misemployments of our naďveté
work all too well, occasionally giving birth to a "cult-fad" or "cultural
phenomenon."
It goes without saying, though, that once a formula for success has been
established, the wave of would-be imitators held back by their own unimaginative
nature champion it as their own, flooding the market with unabashedly derivative
commodities far more economically priced than their brand-name counterparts. It
was strange how on the heels of Pokémon's success, the similarly themed "Digimon"
made it to American airwaves. Such was the case with the "Snorks," Hanna-Barbera's
ill-conceived reaction to the wildly popular success of the Smurfs (albeit, with
less communist rhetoric and subtext).
Now, in the more utilitarian aspects of life, I fall into the pro-genericism camp.
Being thrifty, I've found that an RC Cola is much less of a strain on your pocketbook
than Coke, and just as refreshing. But I bring this up because, a few weeks ago, a
good friend of mine who's had to endure my incessant praise of the Elephant 6
collective for years on end approached me with the Arthurs' debut album and tried
to pass it off as the second coming Christ (i.e. the Beatles). I listened
attentively to the record's first few moments, which boasted a chorus of decidedly
off-key children singing, "Please don't take my sunshine away," before my attention
was diverted to the far more pressing issue of who would win in a hypothetical
fight: Jeff Magnum or the tag-team of Will Cullen Hart and Bill Doss.
It's unfortunate that the Arthurs and I got off on such a bad foot because, for
what it's worth, they're not really a "bad" band. As with any semi-lucrative
psychedelic pop album, Walking in the Sunlight has its fair share of sharp
hooks, hummable melodies, and Liverpudlian meanderings. But these ingredients
alone do not insure an intriguing alchemy. In fact, it's when these structural
cornerstones are prized over good ol' fashioned experimentation (the very source
of psychedelia) that one is faced with such middle-of-the-road
-Kevin Adickes, April 9th, 2002