MOSCOW - President Vladimir Putin leads Russians
in a day of mourning on Monday with his people asking how more
than 100 hostages were killed by mystery gas used to knock out
Chechen guerrillas holding them in a Moscow theater.
As of Sunday evening, Moscow's top doctor Andrei Seltsovsky
said 646 people were still in hospital, including 150 in
intensive care, 45 of them in a grave condition.
Early reports on Saturday said only around 10 hostages had
died, suggesting that the operation had been more successful
than had first seemed possible.
But the death toll rose inexorably. During Saturday it hit
67, then over 90, before reaching 117 on Sunday. Only two died
from gunshots. Asked what had killed the other 115, Seltsovsky
said succinctly: "The effects of the gas exposure."
The injuries and deaths followed the seizure of a Moscow
concert hall by armed Chechen rebels, bent on forcing Russia to
withdraw from their republic, on Wednesday.
For President Vladimir Putin, the rising death toll was an
uncomfortable reminder of two other tragedies which have
blighted his term of office.
In August 2000, the nuclear submarine Kursk sunk after a
torpedo exploded on board, killing 118. Putin was widely
criticized for a perceived failure to act decisively then.
Earlier this year a helicopter was shot down over Chechnya
with a similar number of deaths, despite Putin's repeated
claims that the Chechen war, launched in September 1999 --
months ahead of the election which made him president -- was
all but over.
ALFA TROOPS
After the guerrillas had shot two hostages dead, one of
them early on Saturday, crack Alfa troops stormed the theater,
first pumping in an unknown gas which knocked out both hostages
and rebels.
Officials said they were forced to use the gas to stop
several women fighters seated among the 750 hostages detonating
explosives strapped to their waists.
The storm troops then took on the remaining rebels in the
rooms and corridors of the second floor in close-quarter
combat.
Putin apologized and asked for forgiveness for the deaths,
but televised scenes of desperate relatives clamoring outside
hospitals for news of their loved ones and being pushed back by
police did little to boost his image.
A failure to identify the gas -- and claims that it was a
drug similar to general anesthetics used in routine surgery --
also helped reinforce a long-standing image of Russian secrecy
and disinformation. Dr. Peter Hutton, head of Britain's Royal
College of Anesthetists, said he knew of no medical anaesthetic
gas that could have been used in the way the gas was used in
Moscow.
"It's almost certainly something that's developed, owned,
and used only by the military," he said.
Paul Beaver, of the London-based security and defense
consultancy Ashbourne Beaver Associates, said the operation
would be considered a success in military terms, defined as
fewer than 30 percent casualties.
But he said most military gases have antidotes and it may
have been a flaw in Russian planning that they launched their
attack without making sure they had enough antidote on hand to
treat all the hostages for poisoning.
He was backed up by Lev Fyodorov, president of a Russian
chemicals security pressure group, who said troops failed to
give an antidote to those affected by gas when they were still
in the theater, or once they had dragged them out onto the
street, or even when they got them to hospital.
Moscow's top anesthetist, Yevgeny Yevdokimov, made clear
that doctors had been hampered by the fact that they did not
know what gas they were dealing with.
Russia now faces possible strains in relations with its
partners as it continues to portray its Chechen policy as an
anti-terrorist operation along the lines of the U.S.-led
coalition against the al Qaeda network in Afghanistan.
On Sunday the foreign ministry summoned the French
ambassador to complain about a pro-Chechen rally held in Paris
on Saturday.
The ambassador, Claude Blanchemaison, was also told Russia
was deeply concerned that Denmark, which holds the rotating
Presidency of the European Union, had not denounced a planned
World Congress of Chechens in Copenhagen.
Moscow has threatened Putin may cancel a forthcoming trip
to Denmark if the gathering went ahead.