WASHINGTON - The United States on Monday said
Russia faced "no easy way out" of the theater siege by Chechen
rebels that left 117 hostages dead, and said the blame lies
with the "terrorists" rather than the Russian government.
A gas used by Russian special forces to end the crisis on
Saturday killed 115 of the hostages, and the United States has
asked for an explanation of the assault.
Russian officials have refused to identify the gas, even to
doctors trying to treat the ill. Representatives for the State
Department and Pentagon said they did not know what gas was
used.
President Bush blamed the rebels who occupied the theater
for three days rather than Russian President Vladimir Putin,
White House spokesman Ari Fleischer said aboard Air Force One
as Bush flew to New Mexico on a campaigning trip.
"The president feels very strongly that the people to blame
here are the terrorists; the people who caused this tragedy to
take place are terrorists who took hostages and endangered the
lives of others," Fleischer said. "This is a tragedy ... but he
understands it is the terrorists with whom the blame lies."
The United States has been waging its own war on terrorism
by trying to destroy Osama bin Laden's al Qaeda network, which
it blames for last year's Sept. 11 attacks on America that
killed about 3,000 people.
U.S. Embassy officials in Moscow, who visited hospitals and
other locations, found what they believed to be the body of one
U.S. citizen, but they were awaiting final identification.
They also found another American who had been inside the
theater and was currently in "stable condition," and a U.S.
permanent resident who was "also recuperating from injuries,"
State Department spokesman Richard Boucher told reporters.
"The Russian government was faced with a difficult dilemma
as a result of this cruel terrorist act. There was no easy way
out of this situation, in which armed terrorists were
threatening the lives of so many people," he said.
Boucher said the U.S. view on resolving the Chechen
conflict remained that a "political settlement" was required.
"There's no military solution in Chechnya for either side
and there's certainly no solution from terrorism," he said.
Boucher said the United States did not know in advance that
the Russians were going to use gas in the rescue effort of
about 750 people held hostage by about 50 Chechen rebels, some
with explosives strapped to their bodies.
'THEIR WACO'
"It's their Waco," said Harvey Kushner, a criminal justice
expert at Long Island University.
About 80 members of the Branch Davidian cult died in 1993
in Waco, Texas, when their compound burned down. Federal agents
had used tanks to poke holes in the buildings to insert tear
gas in an attempt to end the 51-day standoff and force the
group out in the open.
Kushner said that in both the Moscow and Waco situations,
authorities "should have continued to talk and tried to
negotiate."
National security experts speculated that the type of gas
used was an opiate or some type of general anesthetic.
"For years people dealing with hostage incidents have been
seeking the magic substance that would solve their problem -
an odorless, non-lethal, instantaneous knockout gas," said
Brian Jenkins, a senior terrorism expert at RAND, a U.S. think
tank.
But such a substance did not exist because the impact on a
person depended on weight, age and physical condition, Jenkins
said. "There is no such thing as a standard dose that covers a
very diverse population."
Russian authorities had to make the calculation of the
number of people whose lives could be saved in making their
decision to use the gas when faced with armed attackers who
could detonate explosives and cause hundreds of casualties and
possibly bring the structure down, Jenkins said.
"Probably, just on the kinds of calculations one would
make, going in to some type of assault without the gas would
really have been a very high risk," he said.
Kushner said the Russians may have been deliberately harsh
in their methods to send a message to the rebels of the
consequences for such action.
"In a way it was very heavy-handed that you had innocents
dying, but again they're dealing with a very serious terrorist
problem," Kushner said. "And so the message went out - we're
not going to take anything from you guys."