David Kilgour
A Feather in the Engine
[Merge; 2002]
Rating: 8.0
There are a lot of ways that music can be beautiful. A lot of
times, we hear something as pretty simply because we're
conditioned that way. Frequently, beauty and grandeur are the
result of careful planning and composing, like Samuel Barber's
"Adagio for Strings" or Vivaldi's summer violin concerto. I
suppose there are certain cliches that have emerged in Western
music as it's gradually become codified into a system of keys
and chords and standard arrangements that we've collectively
come to view as "ugly" and "beautiful." The way we listen to
music is defined by our cultural surroundings, and our
surroundings tell us that minor keys are sad and major keys
are happy (generally speaking).
On the other end of the spectrum, there's a different kind of
beauty to found in less strictly composed, more free-flowing
music. You can hear it in Shuggie Otis' "Freedom Flight"
or the first track on Boredoms' Vision Creation Newsun.
There's a certain point where some improvised music suddenly
ceases to be subject to pretense-- it's just there and you
take it for what it is. On a personal level, I think this is
why I find listening to Japanese koto music and Javanese gamelan
orchestras to be somewhat liberating. Somewhere in all that
sound, you can catch a rather vivid glimpse of the soul of the
person or people playing it.
Naturally, I enjoy both music that's intricately composed and
music that's totally free of any compositional guidance. A
Feather in the Engine, David Kilgour's fourth solo album
(excluding his mid-90s compilation of demos, First Steps
and False Alarms), plays something like a meeting point
between the two ends of the spectrum. On the one hand, you
have several smartly written psychedelic pop songs, ensconced
in the traditions of Kiwi rock that Kilgour's own band, the
Clean, helped establish. On the other, you have a handful of
simply gorgeous off-the-cuff guitar instrumentals that
transcend any other little subgenre distinctions you could
apply to Kilgour's music.
The album opens with one of these instrumentals, a meandering,
meditative track called "Sept. '98" that makes me want to get
out a good throw rug, find a mantra and have a good moment of
escape from my oft-overbearing superego. Kilgour's guitar
lines seem to flow with his stream of consciousness, and the
several overdubbed parts combine for a shimmer effect. An
unassuming organ interjects now and then with quasi-melodic
phrases that provide a good contrast to the simple themes
Kilgour works out on his guitar. One urgently strummed
passage even recalls Jorma Kaukonen's "Embryonic Journey"
from Jefferson Airplane's Surrealistic Pillow.
The album moves from there to the quirky pastoral psych-pop
of "Slippery Slide," full of tumbling piano flourishes,
percussive, plucked bass, and relaxed acoustic strumming.
Kilgour's singing isn't exactly what you'd call world-class,
but his subdued tenor works just about perfectly for this kind
of thing. "All the Rest" follows with a more focused pop hook
and a strong backbeat. Kilgour doesn't pay much mind to
traditional pop song structure in his writing, though, and
this songs is no exception, as he lays into his wah pedal for
an extended midsection that provides the record with one of
its Clean-est moments.
Several other songs follow fairly well-paved paths, such as
the fine acoustic "The Perfect Watch" or "Wooden Shed," but
the three best songs come consecutively near the end. "Today
Is Gonna Be Mine" is an exultant blast of prime Flying Nun
brand pop-- ramshackle, yet somehow also propulsive. "I Caught
You" opens with a "Venus in Furs" drone, some repetitive piano
motives and a detached Kilgour singing, "I've got you inside
my head," before cutting into a slippery bass groove courtesy
of frequent Kilgour collaborator Noel Ward over thumping drums.
"Instra 2 Reprise" follows, and though its title may make it
sound like a tossed-off interlude, it's anything but. Kilgour
delivers one of his best vocal performances over subtle
percussion, wah-drenched guitar and a string arrangement by
Graeme Downes of the Verlaines. The string quartet is
masterfully scored to provide counterpoint to Kilgour's vocals
during verses and melodic material between the verses. Brief,
eastern-sounding descending lines alternate with Copeland-esque
crescendos with a swooping violin lead. It's truly fantastic
stuff that succeeds brilliantly without really conforming to
any traditional sense of structure.
Of course, there are also more of those splendid little
instrumentals to be found, like "Instra 2," an acoustic 12
string guitar and tack piano interlude obviously influenced
by the music of South Asia. Kilgour rattles off sitar-like
runs with ease and keeps the harmony ambiguous. The album
closes with "Backwards Forwards," which centers all of its
varied wandering around a few central chords, relying on a
simple cadence to bring everything full circle at regular
intervals. A distant drum machine provides a pace for the
proceedings, which find Kilgour alternately exploring textured
strumming and slow, surf-styled leads dripping in reverb.
A Feather in the Wind is actually a bit too brief at 38
minutes, and you'll barely feel the passage of time while
listening to it. Complaints are hard to come by, as there's
really not a single unpleasant moment on the entire album.
That said, though thoroughly enjoyable, the album isn't always
riveting, either, and occasionally the attention does stray.
But that's hardly a reason not to throw it on when you need
to chill out after a long day now is it? Kilgour has managed
to craft an album that unleashes a hefty dose of beauty on the
world, and that's something we can always use.
-Joe Tangari, March 14th, 2002