Kaia
Oregon
[Mr. Lady; 2002]
Rating: 6.5
I never attended Lilith Fair-- it wasn't really my scene, or rather,
it was a scene that reminded me of tenth grade field-hockey away
games, when we'd traverse the state, listening to the Indigo Girls
and XTC on the school van's stereo. This was 1991: we thought Indigo
Girls' songs were about boys. We believed we were cool, sort of, in
the way only slightly off-kilter, naïve, uptight prep school girls
might define as cool. We spent a lot of time waxing poetic about
private Northeastern colleges and liberal politics and applying
high school-level critical theory to R.E.M. and Cure lyrics. I don't
look back at this part of my life with any great fond reminiscence
or melodramatic despair. It was non-threatening, easy, heavily
estrogenated, and dull. Six years later, when I was invited to
attend Lilith Fair festivities "as a guilty pleasure," the idea
seemed about as appealing as retaking Algebra II.
While I was singing along to Skylarking and speculating over
how many of my field hockey teammates would be able to justify
rhinoplasty after suffering game-time facial injury, Kaia Wilson was
teaming up with Donna Dresch to form Team Dresch in Portland, Oregon.
Their album, Personal Best, garnered critical acclaim and earned
Team Dresch the designation as one of the most outspoken and
recognizable queer-core outfits. Wilson left Team Dresch shortly
after their second release and moved to Durham, North Carolina, where
she co-founded Mr. Lady and split her time between recording with the
Butchies and putting out solo material.
Kaia's latest solo album, the largely acoustic, confessional
Oregon, is an exemplary representation of the under-the-radar,
user-friendly female folk-pop genre. I don't listen to a whole lot of
this stuff, in part due to an irrational hatred of Ani Difranco (to
whom Kaia bears some musical similarity) and all her friends, but
this is a safe bet for anyone who's into that kind of thing.
Oregon starts out with a sweet natured ode to-- I believe--
Amelia Earhart, called "World's Greatest Haircut." It's a fairly
simple major-key acoustic number that builds gradually with broad
harmonies and
light piano.
The predominating theme here, if there is one, is loss. "Mira"
laments the early death of a friend with a country twang and the
backing vocals of Indigo Girls' Amy Ray. In the same vein, "Jasper"
features harmonica and lyrics like, "When Jasper left, he left for
good." Oregon also features a significantly stripped down,
acoustic Cure cover, "Catch," and the jazzy "Storm," which seems to
be the most fully realized song on the album, both in structure and
instrumentation. "Make Me Please" is a great one-minute pop song
played with drum machine and steel drum keyboard setting. This sounds
weird-- and it is-- but I would have preferred more songs in this
vein.
Kaia has a nice voice, an ear for integrating harmony, and a somewhat
distinctive touch on the acoustic guitar. Lyrically, much of the
album is somewhat self-absorbed and confessional, but that's the
nature of the beast. Kaia doesn't take a lot of risks, save for
"Make Me Please" and the goofy new-age keyboards on "Air."
Oregon is the kind of music you expect to hear while browsing
in your local gynocentric bookstore, or wafting from the dorm windows
of peasant-bloused, mooneyed, Birkenstock-ed college girls with
really good skin. It's nowhere near as distasteful as the vast
majority of mainstream mopey girl music out there,but if you have to
ask at this point if it rocks...well, no.
Not to speak pejoratively of our fair readers, but I suspect there
are more than a few of you who shudder when I invoke the name of
Lilith Fair. Likewise, I suspect if a Y-chromosoned rocker had
released a nicely produced, adult contemporary folk rock solo album,
I wouldn't even be writing this review. Kaia's back catalog as a
member of both the Butchies and Team Dresch shows punk rock
tendencies that don't really have a whole hell of a lot to do with
this album. On the other hand, Oregon is a solid, well-written,
well-executed release that probably deserves the attention of the
legions of fans currently shelling out substantive sums of cash to
attend Ani Difranco shows. Well done, for what it is.
-Alison Fields, May 10th, 2002