Rock*A*Teens
Sweet Bird of Youth
[Merge]
Rating: 5.0
Last night, I watched Radiohead perform on "Saturday Night Live." Seeing the band's
incredible performance caused two thoughts to surface in my mind. First of all, I am
a complete fucking jackass for not exhausting every possible resource by which I could
have wormed my way in to the band's recent show here in New York. Secondly, it occurred
to me just how big "Saturday Night Live" has become. Radiohead, the band responsible
for the current #1 album in the United States, have chosen that show as the outlet for
their one televised performance here.
But the influence of SNL doesn't end with its musical guests. A show which has arguably
sucked for approximately 70% of its time on air has given us such memorable characters
as Dana Carvey's Church Lady, Al Franken's Stuart Smalley, and Mike Myers' Linda Richmond,
not to mention movie spin-off after movie spin-off, ranging from the wildly successful
Wayne's World to the moderately less successful It's Pat! These skits and
characters have entered the nation's comedic vernacular in a way that surpasses perhaps
any other television program from the past 30 years. Thus, I am confident that if I make
a joke or reference that alludes to the television program, a majority of those reading
it will understand.
The Rock*A*Teens are not teens, nor do they rock. Discuss.
When I first heard about the Rock*A*Teens, I was quite expecting them to be a dumb, cutesy
pop band along the lines of Junior Varsity. But seeing the band play live a few months ago
made it abundantly clear that, not only does the band lack the peppy, if immeasurably
annoying, energy of a kitschy pop band, but seemed to take a sharp curve in the other
direction, going for a lugubrious, swampy, and overall dull sound, instead.
The pretentiously-titled Sweet Bird of Youth is a particularly average-sounding rock
album. The majority of its tracks plod along with distorted guitars, occasional Hammond
organs, and the forced delivery of often tone-deaf vocals. At times, such as on the album's
opening track, this decidedly unoriginal formula is executed rather well. But even when the
Rock*A*Teens are at their best, they stay immensely predictable. Most of the tricks used on
Sweet Bird of Youth that stab at originally have already been done before, and better.
But that's just one reason not to like the Rock*A*Teens. Another is that the band's name has
two asterisks in it, meaning that if you try to rip any MP3s from their albums, your system
will no doubt attempt to reprimand you in some way. Another is that, after seeing the band
play live, I'm convinced that they really just want to be R.E.M. They're scruffy, college
radio-sounding, and from a small town in Georgia-- is this really a surprise?
But these are really just minor issues. My biggest gripe with Sweet Bird of Youth is
that it's in no way spectacular, and far too pretentious for what it is. And despite the
fact that its competent execution may make it their best album to date, awkwardness still
reigns as its primary characteristic. Sorry, guys-- you're the Spartan Cheerleaders of
Merge Records.
-Matt LeMay