Screeching Weasel
Beat is on the Brat
[Panic Button/Lookout!]
Rating: 5.0
First and foremost, be forewarned. All of the material on Beat is on the Brat
has been previously released. The majority of the material on this collection
consists of the band's covering the Ramones' first album in its entirety. This
was done as a lark in October of 1992 and the results were provided in limited
numbers (only 2,000 copies were pressed) in unconventional form (our good friend,
vinyl). Not surprisingly, these originals were quickly spoken for.
So, to quell the
demands of unfulfilled fans far and wide, Screeching Weasel placed a smattering of
the tunes on their b-sides compilation, Kill the Musicians. These four songs
were enough to indicate to the average listener that the entire recording needn't be
a heavily vied- for possession any longer. Despite bolstering the tempo somewhat,
the Weasels remained stubbornly true to the originals in the same type of way--
sometimes compelling but mostly unimpressive-- that a child imitates an adult. Nor
was the band's intention to reinterpret the songs in any groundbreaking sense.
After all, as frontman Ben Weasel rightly considers, "How could we possibly improve
on the songs?" Impressively honest about the material, Ben recognizes its re-release
is "primarily for completists; the casual fan will likely be unimpressed."
The final four tracks contained on Beat is on the Brat originally hail from
the band's Formula 27 EP which, incidentally, is still in print. These songs,
recorded after the band's Bark Like a Dog sessions, represent the last
ones (at this point) recorded with on- and- off members Vapid and Panic, and
generally represent some the band's strongest efforts since their temporary recess
post, 1994's How to Make Enemies and Irritate People. On a personal note,
these songs, upon their release in 1996, built within me hopeful expectations that
were sorely mismatched by the band's recent Television City Dream, which is
to say in my needlessly qualified way that they're darn good!
And so, with a final sweeping caveat, I bid the avid collectors among you not to
expect much more than a proper positioning in your record collection if you insist
on purchasing this product, and to the others, remember the Formula 27 EP is
cheaper, and still in print.
-Kevin Ruggeri