WASHINGTON - The United States on Tuesday
scrambled to assure Saudi Arabia that U.S. policy toward its
Gulf ally had not changed after reports of a briefing to a
Pentagon advisory panel depicting Riyadh as an emerging enemy
and backer of terrorism.
Secretary of State Colin Powell telephoned Saudi Foreign
Minister Prince Saud al-Faisal to tell him that President Bush
did not view the longtime Gulf ally as a potential enemy.
Sources familiar with the July briefing, including former
U.S. officials, told Reuters on Tuesday that an analyst from
the private Rand Corporation told the Defense Policy Board that
Washington should press the Saudis to stop funding militant
Islamic outlets worldwide and halt anti-U.S. and anti-Israeli
statements in the kingdom.
White House spokesman Scott McClellan, asked if Bush felt
Saudi Arabia was doing enough to fight terrorism, said, "Yes."
"Saudi Arabia is a long-standing friend and a long-standing
ally. We very much appreciate the way they are cooperating in
the global war on terrorism," he told reporters flying with
Bush to Texas.
Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld also quickly attacked the
leak from a classified briefing, stressing it was one analyst's
opinion and represented neither the views of the U.S.
government nor the advisory Defense Policy Board of former top
government officials and military officers.
"I just think it's a terribly unprofessional thing to do.
It's harmful in this case ... because it creates a
misimpression," he told Pentagon employees in response to
questions about a report by The Washington Post about the
briefing by Rand analyst Laurent Murawiec.
'PURE FICTION.' SAYS SAUDI SPOKESMAN
"Of course Saudi Arabia is like any other country. It has a
broad spectrum of activities and things, some of which
obviously ... that we agree with and some we may not," Rumsfeld
said.
Saudi Arabia was a key U.S. ally in the 1991 Gulf War
against Iraq and has bought billions of dollars in American
arms and provided bases for U.S. forces in the region.
While the Bush administration and the conservative Saudi
leadership have remained friends and allies publicly, some U.S.
officials have privately voiced deep concern over Islamic
militancy in the kingdom and Saudi support of fundamentalist
education throughout the Muslim world.
Saudi Crown Prince Abdullah's foreign policy adviser, Adel
al-Jubeir, told Reuters in a telephone interview from Saudi
Arabia that the analyst's views were "pure fiction."
"They fly in the face of reality and in the face of
history," he said. "Our two countries have been friends and
allies for over 60 years and the relationship has gone from
strength to strength. To describe our two countries as having a
relationship of enmity is ridiculous."
Rumsfeld said in response to questions at the Pentagon
meeting that a number of aircraft hijackers involved in the
Sept. 11 attacks on America were Saudis, but he said "there are
those issues that Saudi Arabia is wrestling with just as other
countries are wrestling with."
HARSH ASSESSMENT OF SAUDI FUNDAMENTALISM
Saudi Arabia, along with many Middle East and European
allies of the United States, has expressed strong reservations
about any U.S. attempt to invade Iraq and oust Saddam Hussein,
who Washington says is developing chemical, biological and
nuclear arms.
Sources familiar with the briefing, who asked not to be
identified, declined to provide details of the July meeting of
prominent intellectuals and former senior U.S. officials and
retired officers, who provide advice to the Defense Department
on policy.
But the Post reported direct quotes from Murawiec, who it
said provided a harsh assessment of Saudi Islamic
fundamentalism.
"The Saudis are active at every level of the terror chain,
from planners to financiers, from cadre to foot-soldier, from
ideologist to cheerleader," the Post reported Murawiec as
saying. "Saudi Arabia supports our enemies and attacks our
allies."
The briefing urged U.S. officials to target Saudi oil
fields and overseas financial assets if the Saudis refused to
stop funding Islamic fundamentalist outlets around the world
and halt anti-U.S. and anti-Israeli statements in the kingdom,
according to the Post.
Members of the Defense Policy Board include former Vice
President Dan Quayle, former Secretary of State Henry
Kissinger, former Defense Secretaries James Schlesinger and
Harold Brown, former House of Representatives speakers Newt
Gingrich and Thomas Foley; and several retired senior military
officers.
The Rand Corporation, a prominent think tank, issued a
brief statement on Tuesday saying that "the briefing prepared
by Laurent Murawiec was not a Rand research product."
"It represents one personal contribution to an ongoing
policy debate on which there are a wide range of views within
Rand and elsewhere," it said. "The opinions and conclusions
expressed are those of the author and should not be interpreted
as representing those of Rand or any of the agencies or others
sponsoring its research."