Chris Whitley
Dirt Floor
[Messenger]
Rating: 9.4
Singer, songwriter, and guitar virtuoso Chris Whitley spent eight long years trying
to meld his abundant talent into a great album. After the release of his 1991 debut,
Living With the Law, he appeared poised for success. Producer Daniel Lanois
tempered Whitley's Texas- tinged folk blues with his own atmospheric pop, and on the
wings of the single "Poison Girl," the album enjoyed critical acclaim and even some
radio play.
Feeling that he'd been forced to make Living commercially viable,
Whitley let his bitterness stew for four years before releasing the vitriolic and
aptly titled Din of Ecstasy. A tome of Hendrix- influenced electric noise,
Din was a curious follow up to Whitley's earlier success and drove off all
but his most ardent fans. Whitley started to get it right on 1997's Terra
Incognita, skillfully combining his roots- rock base with Din's harder
edge. However, his years of silence and stylistic oscillations had taken their toll.
The album didn't sell and Whitley found himself looking for a label.
At the same time, Whitley lost colleague Jeff Buckley to the murky waters of the
Wolf River Marina. Sharing Buckley's penchant for sensually spiritual lyrics and
obviously influenced by his vocal pyrotechnics, Whitley mourned Buckley's passing
by sequestering himself in a room with his National guitar. When he emerged, he had
the skeleton of Dirt Floor.
Recorded in one day at his father's barn in Vermont, Dirt Floor is nothing
short of Whitley's redemption. The credits say it all: "Vocals, Guitar, Banjo and
Foot Stomp by Chris Whitley." The album is a collection of nine starkly sublime
tracks, and considering its lack of apparent whistles and bells, Dirt Floor
is an amazingly complex album. Whitley's tales range from the bluntly visual "Wild
Country," perhaps the album's finest tune, to the cryptically emotive "Accordingly;"
from the quietly ferocious "Altitude" to the almost jazzy "From One Stand to
Another."
If Whitley took his guitar cues from Hendrix on Din, his inspiration on
Dirt Floor is the innovative, instrumental guitarist John Fahey. Like Fahey
did in the sixties, Whitley transforms the traditional instruments of folk, blues
and country into his own musical vision. On the killer's treatise "Ball Peen
Hammer," the banjo in Whitley's hand is urgent and mean. Combining his emotional,
pyscho- sexual vision, the blues' outlaw tradition, and his tinny, pleading guitar
licks, Dirt Floor is a union of Nirvana and a Folkways field recording.
It's a beautiful album-- original yet traditional, simple yet complex. The songs are
timeless; they sound as if they just as easily could have been penned in 1888 or
1938 as 1998, and we could still be listening to them in 2028. The one drawback of
the album is its length. Its nine songs run only 27 minutes, but I've already come
up with a solution: when the album ends, play it again. With each listen, Dirt
Floor reveals something new.
-Neil Lieberman