Tom Ze
Postmodern Platos EP
[Luaka Bop/Warner Bros.]
Rating: 6.7
Upon my pal Brent DiCrescenzo's suggestion, I've been digging on the
recent Luaka Bop compilation of the "best of" the 1960s psychedelic
tropicalia band Os Mutantes. If you'll recall, Brent raved about them a
couple of weeks back, hyping their use of the Beatles' White Album
recording techniques three years before the Fab Four had even conceived
that album's existence. He was right, too-- Os Mutantes pretty much got
it goin' on. I urge fans of recent Stereolab and Beck LPs to make a
journey to the record store, posthaste. (Fuckin' do it, then!)
Tom Ze's one of those 60's tropicalia guys. That's the blinding flash of
brilliance I'm able to present on Ze's musical background. Y'know, he
worked the same scene as Os Mutantes and Brazilian genius Caetano Veloso,
drawing influences from everything from bossa nova and samba to American
protest songs and Morricone soundtracks. But you know remixes these days--
they're not concerned with maintaining the original feel and emotion of
the music. Rather, today's remixers take minor elements from the LP
versions and warp them with experimentation. The end product is invariably
a completely new track that incorporates a few samples from the original
song.
This is fine by me, as long as the remixers are competent musicians that
can produce something that is not only worth listening to, but that the
original artist would deem worthy of bearing their name. In the case of
Postmodern Platos (I don't think they're referring to Dana Plato,
better known as Kimberly from "Diff'rent Strokes"-- God rest her soul),
we've got five fantasmoid remixes, and a straight, previously unreleased
Ze track.
The selection of artists remixing Ze's material is top-shelf, if a bit
predictable. It opens with the High Llamas' gurgly, liquid Squirm-style
take on "Defect 2: Curiosidade." The keyboards are distinctly Americanized
tropicalia, with jazz organs and studio effects that, at times, seem to
have shot forth from the skilled hands of Nigel Godrich. Tortoise's John
McEntire's version of the same song follows the Llamas' track nicely,
incorporating Brazilian acoustic guitar, a solid bassline, an advanced
samba rhythm and Ze's organic vocals and pitch-perfect harmonies.
Sean Lennon's rendition of "Defect 5: O Olho Do Lago" sounds decent
enough, even if his ideas are somewhat amateurish and obvious (the sample
of the electric drill was more effectively executed by-- and I hate to say
it-- Ministry, on the opening track of 1989's The Mind is a Terrible
Thing to Taste). But Lennon's obviously spent some much-needed time
familiarizing himself with the expensive recording equipment that dad's
legendary recordings paid for. He delivers a slow, punching hip-hop beat
for the first part of the track, and all-out pre-programmed jungle rhythms
for the second.
Amon Tobin turns in some predictably spaced-out, jazzy Brazilian
drum-n-bass for his remix of-- you guessed it-- "Defect
2: Curiosidade." Despite the fact that we've already heard two versions of
the song by this point, Tobin's beats are undeniably refreshing when
pitted against the comparitively stale drum tracks of previous
cuts. When, four minutes into the almost seven- minute- long nebulaic
journey, Tobin breaks out his trademark frenzied rhythmic assault, he
casually casts off the best one- and- a- half minutes Postmodern
Platos has to offer.
Sasha Frere-Jones, who you may recognize from his full-time outfit, Ui, or
from the pages of Spin Magazine, dishes up the EP's last remix-- a
head-bobbing, mellow spin on "Defect 1: Gene" complete with breathy female
vocals. But I can't really be of much help in assessing the quality of
Ze's non-album track, "Canudos," since I'm not yet familiar with his
latest Luaka Bop long-player, Fabrication Defect, the album the
original versions of these songs appear on. I will mention, however, that
its angular guitar part and "hillbilly violin" are enough to make me have
to pee. Take it how you will.
Postmodern Platos works on two levels: it can be experienced by Tom
Ze fanatics as an opportunity to hear hip scenesters' interpretations of a
tropicalia legend's latest work, or by hip scenesters who know nothing
about the guy but are looking for an affordable helping of post-rock and
drum-n-bass. You decide which.
-Ryan Schreiber