Soundtrack
The Book of Life
[Echostatic]
Rating: 5.0
I haven't seen it, but evidently Hal Hartley's latest film, "The Book of
Life" is about Satan, Jesus, Magdelene, and other deities and religious
figures trying to work through the same millennial anxiety that the rest
of us are supposedly dealing with. I suspect it's a pretty serious affair,
and though Hartley's films are generally as unpretentious as they are
serious, something tells me that he's not going to pull this off. Of
course, the idea of Satan hoarding bottled water, ramen and canned baked
beans is pretty irresistible, but I doubt that figures very prominently
into the film.
Now, as I understand it, the soundtrack for "The Book of Life" is as
high- concept as the film-- purporting to be a sort of overview of music
at the end of the millennium. This is asking for trouble. I mean, no
matter how much weird random stuff you put on a record like this, you're
going to leave something out. Sure, Hartley gets big juxtaposition
points for getting the Osnabrucker Boys Choir to stand next to PJ
Harvey, but then he goes and leaves out hip-hop, jazz, country,
Canto-pop and creole marching bands.
Oversight is not the only problem with a survey approach like this,
either. Like so many soundtracks, this one contains a lot of previously
released fodder. Hub, Phylr, Tanako Minekawa, Drazy Hoops and Super 5
Thor all contribute songs which appear on proper albums, and Hartley gets
all postmodern on us by including a song which originally appeared on
another soundtrack, David Byrne's "Machu Picchu." This leads to a pretty
frustrating paradox: if you're a fan of one of these bands, you get nothing
new, and if you hear them for the first time here and decide to seek out
their other recordings, the soundtrack becomes obsolete. It's nice that
the bands are at least obscure, but whether or not Phlyr's same old
ambient/industrial schtick, Hub's sensitive-guy folk-rock or Drazy
Hoops' laidback, breathy acoustigroove deserve wider exposure is another
question entirely.
Devoted PJ Harvey fans will wanna hear the old school crunch of "The Faster
I Breathe the Further I Go," and really devoted Yo La Tengo fans will enjoy
their "Turtle Soup," a two-part instrumental which is pretty throwaway
compared to the excellence of most of their album work. And there are even
a few really good songs on the soundtrack. Some might even find it a useful
document in terms of pointing the way towards some interesting music, but
as a whole, it doesn't hang together very well. Here's hoping the film is
better, and that maybe Jesus does some serious looting or maybe flips over
a couple of cars in it.
-Zach Hooker