Nine Inch Elvis
Nine Inch Elvis
[Invisible]
Rating: 2.9
That's exactly how I reacted. "Good God, this can't be... there's no fucking
way... tell me this isn't..." But it is: Elvis tunes with a Nine Inch
Nails-style industrial makeover. No catch.
You can blink now. This is real, so very, very real. And not even funny to
boot.
And so, remaining faithful to their long, storied history, Invisible Records
has released yet another unbearable listening product. At the helm of this
brilliant idea is a mysterious man using the supposed pseudonym "J. Wilder."
My money is on Martin Atkins-- ex-member of PiL, current member of Pigface,
and founder of the Invisible imprint. In 1995, he also made an album called
An Industrial Christmas Carol. I can't help but think that the same
person who hatched that concept also hatched this one. But it's just a guess.
I wish I could, but I can't digress anymore. Forgive me Lord, for I actually
have to describe the music. As it turns out, not every song sounds like NIN.
The first real track-- after the industrial-noodling of "Beginnings"-- is a
cover of "All Shook Up." The beat is at times more clubby and driving than
Nine Inch Nails, resembling Nitzer Ebb and KMFDM, respectively. The vocals,
meanwhile, are standard industrial fare: monotonous, ominous and muffled.
Wilder retains the dramatic pause between "I'm in love" and "I'm all shook
up," but otherwise, the song sounds nothing like the original. The next track,
"Jailhouse Rock," has more in common with its Elvis version, but this doesn't
make the music any more bearable. Imagine Elvis performing live from Detroit's
largest sheet-metal plant-- all masculine aggression, no stylish swagger.
The songs that are reminiscent of NIN are of the Pretty Hate Machine
variety. All of Reznor's early trademarks are here: a plodding pre-programmed
beat, electronic guitar chords, that zigzagging tin sound, and of course, the
no-brains, all-balls cacophony of angst. "Hound Dog" is "Terrible Lie" meets,
well, "Hound Dog"; its tawdry guitar solo and Cellephania's irritating backup
vocals (possibly an aliased Meg Lee Chin) make it one of the most humbling
moments of torture on the entire album. "Heartbreak Hotel," meanwhile, has
Déjà vu moments of "Kinda I Want To" and "Head Like a Hole." But, in truth,
most of the tracks here have something in common with any number of late-'80s
industrial acts. Thus, to make things worse-- is it possible?-- this album
sounds painfully dated, too.
On the bright side, the lyrics one-up Trent Reznor's. But Mr. Wilder didn't
write them, so I can't give him too much credit in that department, can I?
Surely he realized that the line, "Well, since my baby left me/ I found a new
place to dwell/ It's down at the end of lonely street/ At Heartbreak Hotel,"
is better than, "Head like a hole/ Black as a soul/ I'd rather die/ Than give
you control." Even if only by a bit.
This album is painful. Not razor-cut painful, or even twisted-ankle painful,
but rather headbutting-a-lit-gas-stove painful. I know because I did this
three weeks ago. It hurt. This hurts. I want to laugh with J. Wilder, or at
him, but I can't even do that. Nine Inch Elvis is too painful not to be
taken seriously. So why, then, does Pitchfork even bother reviewing
this tripe? To let you know that this kind of thing is happening in the world,
even here in first-world America. Thousands of people are spending their time
and money on projects like Nine Inch Elvis, and nothing's being done to stop
it. People, join me in the fight. Together we can we stop cochlear cruelty.
-Ryan Kearney