Internal/External
Featuring...
[K]
Rating: 7.6
Well, this is an interesting item. Paul E. Schuster's your average hairless
Olympia-based indie rock scenester. He's worked with a couple of classic
Pacific Northwestern bands-- he was the keyboardist in Some Velvet Sidewalk,
and he played on Julie Ruin's self-titled album and the Spells' Age of
Backwards EP. In short, this is a guy with a lot of rock star friends.
And on the aptly-titled Featuring..., he puts his industry contacts--
people like Kill Rock Stars owner and songwriter Slim Moon, Unwound's Justin
Trosper, Sleater-Kinney girls Kathleen Hanna and Carrie Brownstein, and
Calvin Johnson (among others)-- to good use.
Originally, Internal/External was intended as Schuster's own experimental
electronic project. But after recording the stuff for a year, Schuster
came up with an excellent marketing idea: he'd give the songs to people
from the local music scene and see if they'd be willing to contribute to
the project. Now, I'm not one to question motives, but Schuster's tactics
are a little transparent. Call me a dick, but anyone knows that recruiting
big stars is going to sell records, and get the primary artist's name in
the spotlight. And sure enough, there's a buzz on Featuring...
In a way, this disc isn't conceptually that different from Stephin Merritt's
the 6ths project. The difference is, the 6ths consisted of material written
and recorded entirely by Merritt, with the exception of vocals, which were
added by folks like Lou Barlow, Dean Wareham, and Mac McCaughan. On Schuster's
album, each song is a collaboration. In that respect, it lacks the cohesive
vision of the 6ths' Wasps' Nest, but it's also less predictable and,
when it works, a lot more fun.
As it turns out, Featuring... is a pretty solid affair. After eight
seconds of disposable "Intro," the album kicks off with "Secret Adversary," a
pretty cool slab of dark 80's dance with a shuffling beat and an organ soaked
in reverb. Sadly, Joseph DeRouselle of the Newlyweds louses shit up by
overdubbing shoddy spoken word ("If we had talked about the scenery/ Instead of
our minds' machinery/ There may still be/ An opening/ Or a door or a window or
something") while bandmate Angie Hart tunelessly yowls background lyrics like,
"Technotronic!/ Catatonic!/ I said I know I know I know I know I know!" But
things still come together when DeRouselle and Hart sing in unison: "The lights
are on her."
Lois Maffeo (yes, that Lois) offers a silky love song in "Hope." Its
glossy production adds an air of plushness to the track while Maffeo croons
"Hope, come inside/ I wanna know what I will find." It's definitely the only
time I've ever heard something draw equally from a Spice Girls ballad and
Massive Attack.
The album's highlight, though, comes on early. Three songs in, Schuster's
former bandmate Al Larsen (from Some Velvet Sidewalk) teams up with Carrie
Brownstein (Sleater-Kinney, the Spells) for "The Skin." Brownstein alternates
between a riff lifted from Donovan's "Season of the Witch" and an effectively
distorted minor-key melody over an ominous drone and a base rhythm of quiet
hi-hat taps and bongos. Larsen's panicky vocals echo with drug paranoia and
hallucinogenic lyrics: "I didn't know/ The skin I'm living in/ Is something
I could grow."
But naturally, a lot of these tracks don't live up to expectations. Kathleen
Hanna's "Stepping up to the Mic" basically amounts to three minutes of
pretentious rambling about how, "I felt like I was in a process of continuum,
like some kind of weird historical thing was overtaking me, like I was Patsy
Cline or Queen Latifah or somebody really important. And I realized there
was no time like now and I didn't care if I was scared." (I think Hanna's
melodrama pretty much speaks for itself in this case.)
Sue Fox's "Townes Van Zandt" is far from stellar, too. It's another spoken
word bit (yeah, there's a lot of that) in which Fox outdoes Hanna's track
in terms of self-righteousness by proclaiming her own excellence ("I put
down my mic/ People come up to me/ To tell me how great it was"). How about
exercising a little modesty next time, kids?
You know, I hate spoken word as much as the next guy. What makes Schuster's
Internal/External project different from, say, Exene Cervenka's solo offerings,
is that it's not deep or preachy, and that the music serves as these songs'
creative base instead of being something that "sets the mood." I have to
be honest here-- if you removed Schuster's work from these songs and inserted
standard Olympia lo-fi rock, it'd be a lot less interesting.
But above everything, what makes the album work is that even after several
listens, it remains fresh and unpredictable. While I may diss Schuster for
such an obvious Santana-like gimmick, I can't deny that Featuring...
is a better record than I ever imagined it would be. But as good as it
sounds now, I'm not sure it'll age well. But hey, neither will the Magnetic
Fields.
-Ryan Schreiber