Gossip
That's Not What I Heard
[Kill Rock Stars]
Rating: 6.4
As you may know, last year was extraordinarily busy for the Pitchfork
staff. When we weren't feverishly churning out Modest Mouse and Radiohead
propaganda to the indie masses, we were working just as diligently behind the
scenes-- constructing elaborate altars, carving votives statues, performing
propitiatory rites, and making midnight blood sacrifices to Isaac Brock and
Thom Yorke. Well, I kept up my end of the bargain. Still, I've yet to
see a busload of redhead nubile handmaids pull up to my house, or the promised
air-drop of $7B in cash, or any significant increase in my hoops vert.
While I sit here waiting for divine gratitude to knock, I'll fill you in
on a story you may have missed in the news-heavy clamor of year 2000. It
was recently revealed that, after countless trials, the geneticists that
brought the world Dolly the Sheep were finally successful in splicing the DNA
of Kathleen Hanna with that of George Thorogood. Stranger still: in a shocking
coup for inter-species relations, the resulting embryo was brought to terms by
Glenn Danzig's pet wolf. After weaning the infant off wolf's milk and her
steady diet of Misfits lullabies, the men in lab-coats whisked the child off
to an orphanage in Searcy, Arkansas, where she was assigned a new identity.
Beth, as she was named, matured much faster than her creators could have
anticipated. Then, one night, under a full yellow moon... she vanished!
Well, maybe in a more perfect world. But it sure as hell beats the group's
official bio from Kill Rock Stars: "Beth's pop-gospel voice evokes years
of rough ridin' in love's fast lane, seeing things that would make a
lesser person hit the brakes and have a breakdown." That has serious
theme-song potential if they ever come through on that Joan Jett and Pat
Benetar sitcom they've been promising us. But not for much else.
So, what does the Gossip sound like? In all seriousness, the
Olympia-by-way-of-Arkansas transplants really do sound like a vaguely punker,
female-fronted version of George Thorogood and the Destroyers. At its
growliest, Beth's voice recalls Danzig's early solo work. And, in keeping
with a current trend, this is a bassless outfit. Though Nathan (no, they don't
have last names) holds his own on guitar, the sparse setup wears out quickly.
There's only so much sonic dynamic you can wring out of one barely varied
blues-riff and Spartan drumming. About 24 minutes' worth to be exact.
Unappealing as this admixture might look on paper, there's something a bit
refreshing and fun about That's Not What I Heard. Just not enough to
pay for it. Like nature, music abhors a vacuum; I guess you could chalk it
up to "the world was primed for this sort of thing." Though I couldn't
honestly recommend this album, I'm sure you'd find yourself humming any one
of these songs long after the record has ended. If you like your records with
value range, though, look elsewhere; as with Thorogood and Danzig, all these
songs basically sound the same. Sometimes handclaps punctuate the E-G-E blues
riffs, and maybe a subtle harmony, but basically, it's your standard
heard-one-heard-'em-all fare.
The Gossip was recently awarded the opening slot on a national tour with
labelmates Sleater-Kinney. If they know what's good for them, they'll
tour their asses off and sell themselves on the basis of their live
performance. It's that sort of music. That is, the kind of music that you
wouldn't think of buying if it weren't that the memory of a good live
performance tipped the scales in their favor. If all goes well, they can
shoot a video in a pool hall with a cameo by B.B. King and his Jack Daniels
bottle-shaped guitar.
-Camilo Arturo Leslie