Diamanda Galas
Malediction and Prayer
[Asphodel]
Rating: 5.0
To paraphrase Bum Phillips, Diamanda Galas may not be in a class by herself
but it doesn't take long to call roll. Her uniqueness is partially due to
genetics, as singers with a four- octave range just don't come along very
often. She can both out- bottom that guy from the Oak Ridge Boys and go
higher than Mariah Carey on helium, all with perfect control. This in itself
is impressive enough to make her music worth checking out-- like reading Mark
Leyner or watching Jordan run ball, you have to marvel at the technique even if
it doesn't move you. If you're looking to actually enjoy the music, though,
it's a tougher call.
On Malediction And Prayer Galas applies her talents to live, solo
performance. It's her at a piano, wailing away about shattered lives at a
pitch that could shatter glass. Broadly speaking, Galas is a performer in
the Tom Waits vein, with a perennially fringe theatrical style meant to
challenge listeners. Like Waits, she commands respect from the avant- garde
community, but her music as a whole has an even narrower appeal. It's not
particularly tuneful, the songs are sung in a variety of languages
(shrieking in tongues, as it were), and some of her vocal techniques are
drawn from the free jazz school of passionate dissonance. Basically, she
screams a lot, and there are no other noises to distract you from her voice,
just the Steinway grand, played entirely straight.
Galas has her admirers, and though I'm not one of them, at times I can see
where they're coming from. Now and then there's a moment, a phrase, a piece
of something that you latch onto and understand. The dirge "Iron Lady" opens
the album; a song about execution via electric chair, it's subject matter is
well- suited to Galas' creepy voice. Next is the standard "The Thrill is
Gone," which gets a shrill, out- there reading that is way too much for me.
It begins with an intense, 30- second vibrato screech, and I can't help but
plug my ears when I hear it.
But then we have "My World Is Empty," an absolutely beautiful gospel that
Galas executes perfectly. It is by far the most enjoyable thing on the
album, and points to the fact that she could have a mainstream audience if
she wanted it. But this is, after all, a woman who published a book called
"The Shit of God." So it's no surprise that the next tune, an exceedingly
melodramatic vocal workout sung in what is presumably Hebrew, is completely
baffling. From that point forward it's pretty challenging stuff, and though
I like to think of myself as having broad tastes, I couldn't get into it.
Galas fans will love it and it's worth a try if you're into experimental
vocal music, but most people won't want to bother.
-Mark Richard-San