Edith Frost
Love is Real EP
[Drag City]
Rating: 7.7
"Love is real/ Real is love/ Love is asking/ To be loved." No, this is
not a cover of John Lennon's 1971 (Johnson & Johnson lotion ad) classic.
And it's a good thing, because while Frost would do an excellent cover
of that Plastic Ono Band gem, her song is much more refreshing.
Last year's Telescopic only further proved Frost as one of the
greatest female songwriters of the decade. Songs like the album's intense
opener, "Walk On the Fire," the beautiful "Tender Kiss" and the haunting
"You Belong to No One" displayed her talent for writing stunningly succinct
lyrics and undeniable musical prowess.
Frost also has a knack for enlisting the help of Chicago's musical elite
for her records. Her full- length debut, Calling Over Time, featured
the talents of Gastr Del Sol's Jim O'Rourke and David Grubbs, and Sean O'Hagan of Stereolab and the High
Llamas. Telescopic boasted production by Royal Trux's Neil Haggerty
and Jennifer Herrema (mysteriously credited as "Adam and Eve"). Now, on
Love is Real, her three- song snack between albums, she's brought
along the Sea and Cake's Archer Prewitt, Eleventh Dream Day's Rick Rizzo,
and Sam Prekop on cover art. (Let's talk for a second about Prekop's art,
by the way. The guy's fuckin' awesome. 'Nuff said.)
The title cut off the new EP is Edith Frost at her finest. Her straight-
forward and earnest lyrics have only improved since Calling Over Time.
She now throws out stunningly succinct lines like "Wonder what you're doing
now/ Listen for your telephone call/ Nothing to talk about/ Make up any
reason to stall" so casually that it seems like her second nature. Frost's
vocals have also become increasingly controlled-- she's become capable of
delivering lines like "Is there anything at all to talk about/ My love is
real," implying incredible yearning while retaining her dignity.
Perhaps the most impressive gift Frost has to offer is that she's able to
say so much with so few words. "Between Us" is a sparse love song about
drinking with a fellow musician that serves as a fine example of Frost
being melancholy sans- cheese. "The Last One" is an unexpected slice of
traditional country from Frost who rarely strays far from her folk-pop
roots. Accompanied solely by an acoustic guitar, she executes like it's
the only genre she's ever known. Musically, the track is on par with more
upbeat Gillian Welch numbers, but doesn't seem to connect lyrically.
Love is Real should tide us over until her forthcoming album is
released, if only because the title track is one of Edith Frost's best
works to date. And judging from the sound of this EP, it just gets better
from here. The next album's her Plastic Ono Band.
-Ryan Schreiber