Maggie Estep
Love is a Dog From Hell
[Mouth Almighty/Mercury]
Rating: 2.0
I'm supposed to be reviewing Maggie Estep's new album Love is a Dog From
Hell. Instead I'm contemplating the horrible change that appears to have
come over her in the form of a bad haircut.
I know my job is to judge music, not appearance, but you can't help but
wonder about a punk super-diva who appears on her first album in combat
boots, wild (long) hair and a don't- fuck- with- me stance, and on her second
album is curled up fetally on a hospital bed, with high- heeled, slinky
boots and a sexy suit. Is she trying to tell us she's healed from her days
of being an Angry Woman? And if she is, who wants to hear this album anyway?
I mean, the whole reason anyone liked Maggie (we're on a first name basis) was
the fact that she was the angriest of all angry women. I bought her first
album after hearing half of the song "Hey Baby" in someone's car 'cause she
was not only angry, she was witty and funny.
I have actually listened to her new album. More than once even. And
everytime I thought the same thing: this is her emotional follow-up album?
Because frankly, it sucks. As an artist, we would hope for some evolution.
As a songwriter we would hope for some (key word) new lyrics, and for
$13.99, we would hope for a decent album.
We, as an audience, would be sadly disappointed because there are
only two songs on this album that were even worth making, and only then
if they'd gone on the first album. The first one, "I'm an Emotional Idiot,"
is just classic Maggie Estep. It's one of those songs that's funny 'cause it's
true, and she does a fairly good job expressing both the feelings you
have while involved with someone and the sense of ridiculous inherent in
having them.
The other song worth hearing is "Jenny's Shirt." It's not like a catchy
tune that you want to hum or anything but it's an interesting story and if
you like linear lyrics this is your song. It's a more like hummed poetry
than spoken word or actual singing.
I guess the fact is that I'm an Angry Woman and I look for the same
thing from Maggie. When you aren't actually a singer, you need to market on
lyrics and the lyrics just don't come through. There is more than one
reference to songs on her first album, which is just kitsch, and leads me to
believe she was short on material. My advice to her is: If you're short on
material, don't make a fucking album. I mean, come on! My advice to y'all:
Don't waste your money on this album. Re-listen to the first one or just do
without.
-Rachel Kbendtsen