Crushed Stars
Self Navigation
[Simulcast]
Rating: 6.0
There's still a lot we don't know about stars, but we do know that, because
of differences in mass, angular momentum and binary relationships, not every
star dies in the same way. Some explode as supernovas, others cool down
forever. Still others collapse into black holes, those a bottomless pits
hidden by event horizons. As any fifth grade science teacher will tell you,
anything that crosses an event horizon disappears, seemingly crushed out of
existence without a trace.
Maybe Crushed Stars were referring to famous people when they chose their
bandname-- as in, Laura Linney was crushed when she didn't receive the Oscar
for Best Actress. But that would make Crushed Stars a pretty vapid bandname,
huh? So, let's assume they're actually referring to the original stars-- those
self-luminous bodies of gas sprinkled throughout the universe. Because, if
nothing else, it makes my job of describing Self Navigation a little
easier. Thank you for your cooperation.
Crushed Stars is comprised of multi-instrumentalist frontman Todd Gautreau (of
Sonogram) and Centro-Matic drummer Matt Pence. And, yes, they write songs that
seem to have experienced brilliance in some previous state-- like post-rock
stripped of its ambitious musicianship and accompanied by exhausted vocals.
The music is somewhat luminous, but its pace is that of a dying star; it's not
so much languid as patiently fading, and accepting that it will continue to
do so for hundreds of thousands, if not millions of years. And yet,
paradoxically, this music is celestial only in the sense that it's good for
stargazing.
Take "Letters to Munich," for instance, which is based around Gautreau's hazy
voice, two-drum percussion, slow, rhythmic strumming, and a soft electric
guitar rolling over the same seven notes or so. Throughout the track, other
instruments enter and exit with equal subtlety: mellow trumpets, a
keyboard-generated flute, and a droning trombone. Archer Prewitt is the
obvious reference point-- and thus, by extension, so is Burt Bacharach.
Gautreau even sounds like Prewitt and covers similar subjects, albeit with
more awkwardness: "You were still growing into your frame/ I was still
wondering how you pronounced your name."
Most of the songs here fit the blueprint above. Sometimes the guitar gets a
bit livelier ("Gordon"; "Afterwards"), or the horns and flutes more prevalent
("Tow Truck" and "Presently Scattered," respectively), but these songs all
subscribe to the aforementioned pace and the same reflective, sentimental
lyrics. There are, however, a few anomalies. With its bouncy strumming and
caterwauling drums, "Exit Wound" is the album's only bona fide pop song, and
it exhibits Gautreau's high notes.
While "Exit Wound" provides a welcome boost, the three instrumentals,
unhampered by vocal structure, flesh out the Crushed Stars' sound. "Asleep on
a Bus Near Lowell" is perhaps the least interesting, although its overlapping
guitars befit the title. "Outside the Stars are Falling" is even simpler: a
spare piano, a guitar ascending and descending a three-note scale, and
extraterrestrial humming comprise the majority of the track. But, coupled
with the ambient movements of its final quarter, the stunning result is enough
to make you wish it were night all day long. "Walkabout," meanwhile, provides
low keyboards and a deep, shifty bass to invoke the spirit of a New
Adventures-era REM instrumental.
The album's lyrics suggest a dual meaning to the Crushed Stars' name. In "Liza
in Silver" alone, there are both of the following lines: "She looks just like
her mother/ She looks just like a film star"; "I hold her hand in Sunday
clothes/ We count the stars to tell the time." In mood, Self Navigation
is much more like an event horizon than Event Horizon, the 1997 one-star
sci-fi film starring crushed stars Laurence Fishburne and Sam Neill. But it's
hard to say whether this music disappears before your eyes, like the careers
of Fishburne and Neill, or if it makes you disappear like that inexplicable
celestial phenomenon.
-Ryan Kearney