Leonard Cohen
Field Commander Cohen: Tour of 1979
[Columbia]
Rating: 8.1
Leonard Cohen, the established poet, chose exactly the right time to descend
from Canada, guitar in tow, and steal the hearts of America's English Lit.
majors. Pete Seeger was a bit too old, Joan Baez was busy releasing Christmas
tunes and Bob Dylan covers, and Dylan himself had these hipsters spitting up
their Greenwich Village coffee over his country leanings and increasingly
unliterary lyrics (not to mention that whole electric guitar thing). So, at a
time when singer/songwriters were as plentiful as pot, down came the Canadian
writer with perhaps the decade's greatest singer/songwriter debut, 1968's
Songs of Leonard Cohen. He was wry. He was literary. He was It.
If you know anything about the 1965 Newport Folk Festival, then you know that
the '60s folk community, like the indie rock community of the '90s, was a
righteous, selfish child. But Cohen didn't disappoint his fans, releasing two
more brilliant, spare collections over the next three years. This period,
however, would be his creative, critical and popular peak. By the time he
returned with his last classic album, 1974's New Skin for Old Ceremony,
the pigeon intelligentsia were too busy applauding Baez and Dylan's return to
form, as well as hailing the new breed of singer/songwriters, to raise dust
about Cohen's use of more sophisticated arrangements. He was still wry. He was
still literary. But he was no longer It.
Three more years would pass before his next album-- hardly a prolific pace,
especially for those demanding folkies. A collaboration with the reclusive
Phil Spector, 1977's Death of a Ladies' Man had the potential to be the
defibrillator for Cohen's career, but Spector's suffocating Wall of Sound
rendered the project a failure; even die-hard fans, of which Cohen had many,
found the album disconcerting. Thus, 1979's Recent Songs was received
with perhaps over-exuberant praise from fans and critics alike; the album
was considered a return to his earlier sound, albeit with a handful of
supporting musicians, including the jazz-rock fusion group Passenger and the
backup vocals of Jennifer Warnes and Sharon Robinson. Later that year, Leonard
Cohen took the same studio lineup on tour in support of Recent Songs.
Field Commander Cohen: Tour of 1979, was compiled from three consecutive
December shows at London's Hammersmith Odean, and another show a week later at
the Dome Theatre in Brighton, England. Surprisingly, only four of the twelve
tracks here are from the uneven Recent Songs, and they're among that
album's strongest moments. Less surprising is how faithful they are to the
studio versions, given the identical musical lineup for the album and tour
alike. Thus, "The Window," "The Gypsy's Wife," and "The Guests" all feature
the exceptional violinist Raffi Hakopian, the shimmering, gypsy-ish
fingerpicking of John Bilezikjian (oud, mandolin), Roscoe Beck's deft work
on the fretless bass, and either the two female vocalists or an uncredited
male vocalist who provide a pleasant vocal compliment to Cohen's monotonous
baritone. Unfortunately, "The Smokey Life" also sticks to the blueprint,
retaining the dated keyboards that marred the studio version-- and without
any of the aforementioned accompaniment to conceal it.
There are a few other missteps. For instance, the one cut from Death of a
Ladies' Man, "Memories," is infinitely more grating than the studio version.
Forgoing any sense of tact, Cohen gives the song a full doo-wop makeover,
coating the song-- a sexual fantasy set at a grade-school dance-- with irony.
Another rare low comes near the end with "Bird on the Wire," which isn't served
well by the band: the strings from the original are noticeably absent, and
the song's subtleties are ruined by more dated keyboards, as well as an
unfortunate electric guitar solo.
But the highlights make these moments easy to forget. "Hey, That's No Way to
Say Goodbye," from Cohen's debut, contains some stunning accompaniment, none
of which is obtrusive. Here, as on "The Stranger Song"-- also from his debut--
it becomes apparent that Cohen's baritone, which is served well by an
auditorium, had deepened over the past dozen years and is in peak form.
The closer, "So Long, Marianne," also works with plentiful accompaniment,
making the song's rejoicing chorus, "So long, Marianne/ It's time we began to
laugh and cry and cry and laugh about it all again," even more elating. The
two tracks from New Skin are also standouts; "Lover, Lover, Lover"
contains an exceptional oud solo from Bilezikjian, and "Why Don't You Try" is
far superior to the album version, with a noteworthy sax solo and jazzy vocal
repetition from the backup.
But the finest moment on Field Commander Cohen-- one that makes the
whole album worthwhile-- is the title track. Like all the other performances
here, one never feels claustrophobic, as is sometimes the case with his studio
efforts. Instead of just the guitar and strings of the original, this version
also offers a marching drumbeat and trumpeting synthesizers that deepen the
song's motif and increase its almost unbearable momentum. Of course, it would
be hard to ruin a song with one of the most spine-tingling opening verses
ever written. But I won't quote the verse here, if only to urge you to
experience it as you first should: in song.
-Ryan Kearney