Carter Burwell
Being John Malkovich
[Astralwerks]
Rating: 7.8
In the 1970's and 80's, two men dominated the world of motion picture soundtracks: John
Williams and Ennio Morricone. If not directly responsible for a film's background music,
one of the two probably inspired it. What finally opened the door to other composers was
Hollywood's own laziness. A rapid spiral to artistic nadir with ludicrous PR vehicles like
"Days of Thunder" alienated the thinking public, who turned to independent film for true
entertainment. Once mainstream studios recognized the underlying sense in this low-overhead,
high-return formula, they picked the best of the crop for mass distribution. It's a consequence
of this fleecing of the underground that composers like Carter Burwell have gained popular
attention.
Burwell's early material appeared almost exclusively in films by Joel and Ethan Coen. Due to
the stifling "quirkiness" of these pictures, his compositions were for the most part
unnecessarily wacky; it wasn't until the Coen brothers struck out in 1991 with "Miller's
Crossing" that Burwell's dramatic talents were put to good use. The stirring score he penned
for this criminally overlooked film has since been recycled in a number of major studio
pictures, including "The Green Mile" and a forgettable 1998 remake of "Les Miserables."
After enjoying success with the Coen brothers' Oscar-winning 1996 thriller "Fargo," Burwell
branched out (apparently at the invitation of Michael Stipe, who produced the two films he'd
score next). Following a misguided experiment in electronic music contributed to "Velvet
Goldmine," he composed the score for "Being John Malkovich," the directorial debut of
revolutionary music video maker Spike Jonze.
Jonze was responsible for the hilariously off-key video for Björk's 1997 single "It's Oh So
Quiet;" this relationship earned him a returned favor in the form of "Amphibian," Björk's
contribution to "Being John Malkovich" soundtrack. "Amphibian" is once again startling,
inventive, and obviously, great-- Björk's creativity continues to astound with an orchestra
of vocals and understated harp chords. Fans of her work should purchase the soundtrack for
this one alone.
Burwell's task was scoring the pathos of desire and loneliness. The film for the most part
retells-- as an overt parallel at its beginning illustrates-- a tale of unrequited love. It's
a witty and entertaining script, but about halfway through I recognized Burwell's signature and
made a concerted effort to evaluate the film without allowing his talent to cloud my judgment.
In the end, the score is arguably more powerful than the film; it may be a great story, but
cinematically, it's nothing new.
Whereas the Coen brothers offered a new approach to filmmaking from the start-- a wry,
singularly skewed view of life-- Jonze debuted with a comparatively staid voice. It's Carter
Burwell's uncanny knack for lilting melodies that allows "Being John Malkovich" to resonate
with such childlike wonder; it's as much evidence of Burwell's authoritative talent for
creating a movie's atmosphere as anything else.
-Chris Ott