Orbiter
Mini LP
[Loveless]
Rating: 3.2
Some bands call seven songs an EP, but hey, whatever floats their boat. This
"mini-LP" begins benignly enough with "3 A.M.," a calming track which floats
by on a tasty Rhodes lick and some dreamy, harmonized guitar feedback straight
off Eno's Another Green World. And that's about it for the appeal of
this record. It's on the next track, "Stray Dogs," that the duo of Fiia McGann
and Harris Thurmond, formerly of such Seattle luminaries as Hammerbox and
Miracle Baby, show off their true intentions. The track, like all that follow
it, begins with an intensely generic hip-hop beat, which supports a bland,
loungy melody and McGann's undistinguished crooning. Or Mr. Thurmond. It's
one of the few elements here that actually varies.
The biggest problem, aside from the obvious, is that the group makes no
attempt at populating the songs with anything that might go a distance
toward disguising their threadbare melodies. "Stray Dogs" is composed solely
of dry, clean guitars and bass, and that unchanging drum loop, the lone
formula implemented on every track. Laid back, pseudo-funky rhythms, jazzy
clean strumming, and multi-tracked vocals are main ingredients. Unfortunately,
they don't appear to have any of the facility for manipulating sounds in the
studio that this kind of music usually requires.
Once the initial melody
fails to grab you, you'll be equally thrilled to discover that there's
absolutely nothing else in store. Guest keyboardists and drummers, present
throughout most of Mini LP, fail to add anything on note; there's
simply nothing going on sonically in any of these inescapably dull songs.
The already aped Eno-esque guitar sound is the most intriguing texture
deployed, and it appears on exactly three songs, not counting "3 A.M.
(Reprise)."
"Sentimental" comes the closest to delivering on the melodic front, but
inexplicably, the production falls apart at the end as the song drags on
minutes longer than necessary, the instruments dropping out one at a time.
And it doesn't even sound intentional. It sounds like each player flubbed
and then gave up. Given that the production is otherwise pristine and
airless, this odd moment is all the more befuddling and distracting. In fact,
it's just about the most interesting point. Sadly, it's just one moment out
of 25, and the rest don't cut it. Shoulda stayed in Miracle Baby, guys!
-D. Erik Kempke