And You Will Know Us by the Trail of Dead
Madonna
[Merge]
Rating: 8.4
Fuckin' emo. Why is every decent indie rock band automatically pegged as emo
these days? Is it because the genre spawned such "groundbreaking" acts as Pedro
the Lion and Bright Eyes? While critics lazily lump creative bands like the
Dismemberment Plan and Les Savy Fav alongside Wolfie, an entirely new genre
is being born.
I recently saw the Austin, Texas-based band And You Will Know Us by the Trail
of Dead classified as emo in a review. How?! Explain that, please. Never
once during the entirety of Madonna does this band mention calendar
months, a girlfriend's eyes, lunchboxes or swingsets. No, they might not be
singing about anything as meaningful as sunshine and rainy hearts, but they
deliver volume, passion, talent, and original hooks.
"There is nothing left to say that has not been said" is the defining line
of Madonna's opening track, "Mistakes and Regrets." You can see where
the guy's coming from with that statement, too. For every perfectly phrased,
eye-opening thought that comes out of rock music, there are a million indie
pop bands singing about holding hands. Yet these guys manage to pull off
more than just a few inspired lyrics.
Trail of Dead also manage unpredictability. From intro to verse, it's
impossible to know what these guys are going to pull out next. "Totally
Natural" begins with a distant tinny guitar and a gently-picked
clean-channel electric before the crashing attack of massive drums enter,
fueling the raging guitars and surreal, screamed vocals about a movie star.
Halfway through, the song slows for a spoken verse, and then quickly changes
into a frenzy of beaten noise and an explosive ending.
You know, people have been saying for a while now that what makes a good band
is not as much having actual talent as it is having a great attitude. Sorry,
but we've been fed a load of bullshit. As these guys prove, it's not only
about having talent, but knowing what to do with it. So, as emo attempts to
stretch its 15 minutes out for as long as it can, bands like Les Savy Fav, the
Plan, and Trail of Dead will probably be happy to help kick it while it's down
by ushering in a new kind of music.
-Ryan Schreiber