Juliana Theory
Understand This is a Dream
[Tooth and Nail]
Rating: 7.3
Listening to Juliana Theory's talent for passionate restraint, as
evidenced in their latest offering, I'm reminded of a comment once used
to subtly criticize a band I used to play in. Mind you, I don't recall
the exact words used in the damning praise, but it was something to the
effect of, "They have all the heart of Samiam, but half the spunk," or,
"Sounds like a Samiam that forgot to drink its morning coffee." Though
it was certainly an honor to be even remotely likened to one of the
greatest bands that has ever set foot upon this blessed earth (do you
sense bias, or is it just me?), the cold recognition of our not quite
achieving the same caliber of success was still painfully real.
I say this to partly congratulate the Juliana boys, but also to call
attention to some of their new album's failings. If the power of both
the album's alpha and omega was replicated throughout the work, these
gents would be the next emo sensation. This isn't meant to suggest
that what comes between these magical musical bookends is stewing in
ass- gravy, just that tracks one ("Black Metal Stars") and ten ("All
That Deth Jazz") happen to come closest to a rather impressive song
I heard previously from the band: a song emotional without being sappy,
melodic without being vapid, guitar- oriented without going the way of
cock- rock.
The stuff between the proverbial Oreo shells is inconsistent. Some of
it rocks with the thundering intensity of a thousand jackhammers
burrowing into secluded stone, while other tracks whimper along,
occasionally redeeming themselves in the end. Musical reminisces
include relatively unknown fellow Seattlellites Alcohol Funnycar in
more aggressive moments, and the new and arguably improved Jimmy Eat
World, during the softer sections. (In fact, "Show Me the Money" bears
more than a comfortable resemblance to Jimmy Eat World's much stronger,
"Believe in What You Want.")
The overall impression is a favorable one, but the Juliana Theory might
want to consider putting a bit more pep in the step. If they accomplish
this delicate task, new day darlinghood won't be far away.
-Kevin Ruggeri