Tarnation
Gentle Creatures
[4AD]
Rating: 8.1
Like the lonesome twang of Johnny Cash's guitar on a warm, summer Louisana
night, on the rickety old wooden porch, under a full moon, with the crickets
and the cornfield just a few feet away. There's your visual-- now let's talk
about the album.
4AD recently severed ties with Warner Bros. and Elektra Records, effectively
putting a bunch of their titles out of print in the United States. Luckily,
4AD won't let these gems go unheard, so they're reissuing 'em like hotcakes.
Tarnation's Gentle Creatures was released back in 1995 to much critical
acclaim. They followed it up a couple of years ago with their major label
debut, Mirador, an album that, despite a great deal of sameness, was
pretty damn good. (Except for a non- Tarnation- penned track called "Little
Black Egg," which, quite frankly, sucked ass.)
Listening to Gentle Creatures now, it actually seems somewhat better
than Mirador. There's more studio trickery (the opening track, "Game
of Broken Hearts" sounds like it's being played off a mono-pressed 45 on a
1950s Wurlitzer), and the songs sound more like authenic classic country.
Vocalist Paula Frazer emulates the ghosts of Loretta Lynn and Patsy Cline
to perfection-- if she hasn't endured years of vocal training, she's some
kinda reincarnation.
Sure, there are tracks I could live without, like the cloying duet "Listen
to the Wind" and the sickeningly melodramatic "Halfway to Madness." But,
for the most part, Gentle Creatures comes through. "Game of Broken
Hearts" is the loneliest country ballad this side of "Cryin'," and "Two
Wrongs Won't Make Things Right" sounds like it came straight out of "Coal
Miner's Daughter." So that's the deal about Tarnation's debut record.
Do you want it? Just ask yourself... do you want it?
-Ryan Schreiber