Super XX Man
Volume V
[Post Parlo]
Rating: 4.9
Now that Dubya's ham-fisted approach to dealing with nuclear powers has put
the entire free world into jeopardy of atomic annihilation, I worry more about
the future. Science tells us that after the inevitable nuclear war that
results from this frat boy attitude toward diplomacy wipes out 99% of life on
the planet, the only lifeforms to survive will be cockroaches and
singer/songwriters.
Exhuming their green-glowing, Geiger guitars from the ashes of civilization,
crafting makeshift recording devices from cannibalized PDAs, they'll claim
the post-apocalyptic earth as their own. Nothing will stand in their way.
The world will be repopulated by those who feel compelled to compose, record
and perform the way roaches have a similar instinctual compulsion to reproduce,
scurry about and get in the teacups. Dismal, yes.
Super XX Man (aka Silver Scooter's Scott Garred), has been at this intimate,
documentary songwriting project since 1994, when he began releasing a string
of volumes. One gets the sense that nothing less than an atomic bomb would
have a shot at stifling him. Super XX Man can't really be called a side
project, though, since Garred started putting his thoughts and feelings down
on tape with the regularity of a core dump before starting his more well-known
band.
Musically, there's not much to this threadbare arrangement on Volume V.
It's thirteen tracks of guitar-based folk-pop with a drum machine and
occasional ukulele here or odd synth there. With so few ingredients to work
with, it's a shame that his voice isn't a bit stronger or more distinctive.
While certainly capable of carrying a tune, Garred has a sort of plaintive
Everyman thing going on with his vox. I guess you could call that an asset.
I don't.
After a boring start that serves mainly as a primer for what to expect-- warm,
simple strums, a programmed rhythm, and enough introspection to choke a
therapist-- "You Dream Fast" follows early and is the easily the strongest
contender on Volume V. Half-creepy lyrics ("these are the things that
fly out of me in the nighttime") are delivered with a sunny pop sensibility.
A less-straightforward touch on the drum-bot really gives the song a bouncy
pomp. It's over far too soon, though, and the disc is never again this
successful with its album-long attempt at personal poetry and evocative
melody. I hope for Super XX Woman's sake that Super XX Man doesn't peak this
early in everything he does.
Two songs later, "Lonely Old Night" displays a tenderness that's found in
Neil Young's (one of Garred's influences) Harvest Moon-era releases.
The only song with backup vocals, the lyrics are plain and homely, but sturdy.
But by the time the next track, "All Night Diners," begins, a weariness
overcomes the listener, and the downward slide begins. "Why do people cry at
all-night diners?/ Why do they say goodbye so soon?/ Sometimes I dine alone
in the springtime/ That's when I sing my lonesome tune." Good grief, Charlie
Brown.
Unfortunately, the reaction I had to Volume V is similar to how a kid
reacts to a long, cross-country drive-- I began wondering when it would end
almost as soon as it began. Maybe it would have been better for Super XX Man
to stick to EPs and sevens, the forms that previous volumes took. Would have
made for a shorter trip and less carsickness.
This sort of diary pop may appeal to voyeurs or relatives. I'm sure that,
for the grandkids, these recordings will be an insightful and appreciated
glimpse into the life and mindset of Pappy Garred in his younger days.
If you don't happen to be related to Mr. Super XX Man, though, you can always
pry into his personal history a bit by listening vicariously. If that's what
gets you off. In our increasingly voyeuristic society of "reality" TV addicts,
that kind of invasive intimacy may just be the wave of the future. Then again,
"Temptation Island" has never had much in the way of artistic merit.
-John Dark