Kate St. John
Second Sight
[All Saints/Thirsty Ear]
Rating: 6.6
Two related truths about pop musicians: give them long enough and
they'll all make an album with bowed instruments. You just wait, ten
years from now, Marilyn Manson will either be dead, a Born Again
Christian minister or recording a wimpier album with Kronos Quartet.
Kate St. John, on the other hand, was weaned on the orchestral world.
Her work on woodwinds has earned her slots on albums by the Dream
Academy and Van Morrison (to name just two). Yeah, she was a sessions
musician, but her second solo album shows that she's more than just
sessions material.
St. John's wispy vocals tiptoe around a simmering chamber orchestra
throughout Second Sight. There's a lot of French in her vocal
style (her song "J'attendrai" is actually sung entirely in French)--
her somber naivete makes her sound like her mind was made up about
love a long time ago, but that she's just now getting around to
telling everyone about it. It's spare and pretty, rather than
precious or lush like many pop singers have accidentally reduced
chamber arrangements to.
Because of her background, St. John's arrangements-- from the romantic
duet "My Lonely Love" to the morose ballad "Fireworks"-- never sound
thrown together. These aren't songs written on a guitar and made to
fit in an orchestral environment; they're chamber songs that happen to
fit in pop shrinkwrap. Though sometimes the lack of a pop foundation
makes you feel like you should be wearing a tux, Second Sight
is a piece of upper crust entertainment that avoids pomposity and goes
straight for songmanship.
-Shan Fowler