Jana McCall
Jana McCall
[Up]
Rating: 6.2
Somewhere along a western stretch of I-80, nestled near a lost highway,
is a place where emotion meets detachment, a place where the ghost of
Hank Sr. hitches a ride in Lou Reed's Studs Bearcat, a place that Mazzy
Star and Cowboy Junkies like to call home. The locals better watch their
backs, though, because there's a new manic- depressive in town. Her name
is Jana McCall.
On her self- titled debut, McCall emerges as a plaintive singer/
songwriter with a penchant for gloom.
Her somber ruminations on love, death and loss, are sung in a
passionless, reverb- soaked voice that heightens feelings of both
spaciousness and isolation. Combining spare instrumentation, slide
guitars ("Mother of Earth") and sloth- like tempos ("Again and Again"),
this is rainy day music for rainy day people, a natural background for a
bathtub session with the collected works of Sylvia Plath.
While it has its moments, the album is solid but unspectacular,
successfully evoking and sustaining a mood but lacking memorable moments.
The songs are well- written but tend to bleed into one another without
differentiation, a quality that lends cohesiveness but ultimately leaves
things feeling a bit flat. When McCall hits it just right, such as on
"Mother of Earth," it's easy to see the talent at work and you can imagine
her making a great album. This isn't it, but with a little more variety
in tempo, instrumentation or theme, McCall could become one to watch.
-Mark Richard-San