AM/FM
Mutilate Us
[Polyvinyl]
Rating: 7.1
In the top right corner of the cover of Mutilate Us, below the bandname
and album title, is a quote culled from the LP's title track: "And if we are
the ones that will cross mountains for love/ Then we are the ones that let
love mutilate us." It's hard to think of a tactic that's more self-congratulatory
than incorporating lyrics into your cover art, especially when they're also
printed in the liner notes. And really, it doesn't benefit much in the way of
advertising. The words are just shy of being trite, and bespeak no insight
that goes beyond the obvious. Plus, the abstract construct of "love" is the
crux of the sentiment. Yuck!
So, it's at least a little surprising that scrupulous ex-Franklin member Brian
Sokel and multi-instrumentalist Michael Parsell's current project, AM/FM,
doesn't come off the least bit smarmy on record. The Philadelphia-based
duo's debut full-length is an unpretentious collection of lo-fi, acoustic-based
pop tunes bolstered by Sokel's warm delivery. AM/FM has the charm and slightly
skewed pop sensibilities of Ween, but in song structure only. Fecal humor and
hallucinogenic abuse, though, might have been intriguing coming from the
Polyvinyl camp.
Mutilate Us successfully skirts stuffiness with light-hearted sincerity.
On the upbeat, "Secretly Odds in Knowing Normal Words," Sokel sings, "You said
I was full of shit/ But what's wrong with that?" backed by bouncy percussion
and hand-claps. "Yours Recklessly" is minor-keyed, folk territory, not
entirely dissimilar from Elliott Smith's recent offerings. It opens on a
wobbly solo-acoustic note, but the song's dense, swelling climax is lovely
pay-off. "Time Flows Much More Slowly This Way" is almost absurd in its
catchiness, and serves as just one of many examples of the adroit songwriting
showcased on the album.
This doesn't mean, though, that Mutilate Us is as consistently great as
the aforementioned tracks. Sokel and Parsell sometimes sink too comfortably
into poppiness and end up tripping over yesteryear's indie rock clichés. "You
and Me at 53" is pedestrian in its aim to emulate the Cars, and its execution
is worse still, echoing latter-day Promise Ring emergencies. "Leanne, The
Seasons Persist" tends toward emo-pop with quiet, building instrumentation
during the verses, but the predictability of the song's explosive between-verse
segues render them completely ineffective.
Still, the occasional misfires of Mutilate Us are forgivable; like most
of the record's tracks, they're brief, often clocking in under two minutes.
When the record is successful, though, it's like a piston blasting warm guitar
pop at incredible speeds. The bulk of the record is so assured that by the
time its last lines are sung (those that adorn the album's cover), it's hard
to not take their genuineness to heart and believe them.
-Richard M. Juzwiak