Pleasure Forever
Pleasure Forever
[Sub Pop]
Rating: 7.5
Heaven's probably pretty cool, I'll admit that. But it's difficult to imagine
what could possibly make eternity that interesting. Would it be like, say, a
continuous orgasm? Because that'd just be messy. Even without the physical
side, it'd get boring really fast if it was happening all the time, like most
everything else. I guess you'd get to be with God all the time, but that
could become pretty tiresome, too. You'd probably have to spend a lot of
time doing menial stuff, like combing airplanes out of his beard, or putting
souls in babies, stuff like that.
So, it's probably fortunate that the experience of listening to Pleasure
Forever doesn't literally correspond to the band's name. Judging from the
band's history, they don't put much stock in names to begin with; originally
known as the VSS, the San Francisco trio also spent a few years as the Slaves
before taking their current designation. Maybe this time, though, the name
will stick; though far from idyllic, the gleefully doomy sound of this
incarnation's self-titled debut transmits the pleasures of musical excess
with more panache and bite than most other would-be epicmakers.
Take the third track, "Meet Me in Eternity." From a hushed opening that pairs
piano with droning guitar noise, the band whips itself into a frenzied
big-rock stomp whose drunken singalong bits make it sound more like Mudhoney
on vaudeville than the deadly serious tour of the underworld suggested by the
lyrics. Suddenly, the storm calms, leaving Andrew Rothbard's smirkingly
sinister vocals to carry the song until the guitars return in a building
staccato thrash that leads right back to the main riff. Rothbard goes out
with rapid gusto, screaming, "You took a piece of me/ And I take it back."
It's one thing for a band to wallow in the dregs of post-grunge sleaze and
hopelessness, but it's something else entirely when they enjoy it this much.
On the opening track, "Goodnight," Rothbard's sly, double-tracked moans crawl
through a Doorsy debauched-cabaret atmosphere, complete with sitar-like
effects and the occasional shrill party-favor whistle, before the thumping,
handclap-heavy chorus enters. We're spared the Lizard King's lyrical
pretensions and left with somewhat standard but effectively dark imagery: "I
take dead aim in a dead-end town/ Your lips seem to part but I can't hear a
sound." Finally, the song breaks down into a menacing sing-song coda,
augmented by some well-placed slidework from guitarist Joshua Hughes.
"Curtain Call for a Whispering Ghost" makes good on the same type of swagger
while Rothbard's piano struts across your skull and tickles at your spine
above drummer David Clifford's ramshackle fury.
The guys are also quite capable of toning down the attitude without losing
their energy. "Bullets" mines far more desolate but still desperate and
driving territory, firing off chilly guitar riffs and organ tones like hot
lead from a getaway car. Putting a different spin on excess, "Stay Precious"
constructs a windswept landscape from armies of guitar and monumental drum
pulses, constantly shifting underfoot and dissolving even faster than it was
built.
Of course, sometimes excess is just excess. What starts in "Any Port in a
Storm" as an enjoyably loopy jaunt through the treacherous pirate-metaphor
seas begins to take on water as it suddenly metamorphoses into baroque chanty,
eventually sinking in its nigh-infinitely repeated, hyperdramatic chorus
call: "All of the things I've lost in search of gold." Likewise, "Magus
Opus" ends up as bloated as it sounds, taking 8½ minutes to crawl through
God knows how many movements and Rothbard's fairly feeble attempts to
convincingly choke out the line, "You enchant the night," in his
million-cigarettes vocals. While they're not completely awful, the fact that
these two are the longest songs on the record (and the fact that they seem
even longer) makes you suspect that Pleasure Forever hasn't yet learned to
manage their excesses.
But who wants a perfect record? Alright, jeez, put your hands down.
Rhetorical question. But think: if you were stuck in a room with Loveless,
Pet Sounds, or any of their goody-two-shoes, genius-level ilk playing
on repeat for eternity, would you feel justly rewarded or forever damned?
While Pleasure Forever might not deliver like the classics, it's got a
dangerous grin on its hellbound face that dares you to tell it so.
-Brendan Reid