Novillero
The Brindleford Follies
[Endearing]
Rating: 6.9
You know, people talk about Canada as if it's just one big, homogenous blob of
moose, ridiculously polite people who say "aboot," and french fries dripping
with vinegar. But it's completely unjust to judge a land of such diversity
with such general stereotypes. I mean, as a New Yorker, I would be really
insulted to hear some Canadian say, "Oh, you're from America, eh? Well, howdy,
y'all! You married your sister, eh?"
No, we've shortchanged our brothers and sisters up North for too long. It's
about time we develop new stereotypes. Better stereotypes. More specific
stereotypes. And what better place to look than Canadian music? I can see it
now: "Oh, you're from Vancouver, huh? Boy, I hear the melodies there are
almost as catchy as the social diseases!" I can't vouch for the accuracy of
the second half of that statement, but I'll bet someone who lives there can.
(Anybody?) Ladies, being hit on by some creep from the lovely city of Toronto?
Simply offer: "No thanks, fella, there's only one Loverboy from Toronto, and
people stopped giving a shit about them ten years ago!"
Designing a witty putdown for Winnipeg, however, is where it gets tricky.
The unassuming Canadian city has been home to such diverse musical talents as
Neil Young, the Crash Test Dummies, and the Guess Who. But Neil Young is old,
nobody gives a damn about the Guess Who anymore, and the Crash Test Dummies
are dead, I think. But if the debut album from Winnipeg locals Novillero is
an indication, some kind of suggestive remark involving horns might be in
store. The Brindleford Follies shows the six-piece band forging a thick
pop sound that is, at times, the perfect soundtrack to an afternoon of
head-bobbing, but suffers from a few weak links, aimless tracks, and
unforgivable lyrical mishaps.
Pop is the name of the game here, folks, and Novillero, at their best, manage
to pull off a really sweet combination of Beulah's horn-heavy, vaguely
psychedelic pop, and the more loose-- sometimes loungy-- sounds of
Nassau-era Sea and Cake. But unlike these two groups, Novillero has
yet to attain their own distinct voice.
The Brindleford Follies flirts with elements of the aforementioned
bands, as well as ska and fingerprints left by retro psychedelic rockers like
the Zombies. The results are a mixed bag. "Ambrose, We Need Advice" suffers
from having been built entirely upon one of the oldest, most played-out chord
progressions known to man. And the fact that said progression consists of two
chords doesn't exactly ameliorate the situation. "On a Canvas, Stained" couples
some nice harmonies and a riveting chorus with a sadly pop-punk-ska verse,
complete with gratuitously syncopated guitar riffage and, yes, horns.
But the most egregious, er, folly on the record comes with "The Day the Trumpet
Player Fell in Love, and Learned to Hate Men." Lyrics such as, "Somewhere in a
chair is a woman with ruby hair/ She has the opinion everything in her life is
unfair," whether or not they're intended ironically, sound purely ridiculous.
The song eventually develops into a not-half-bad pop tune, but what's the
point if you can't get past the opening?
Despite The Brindleford Follies' crappy lows, there are plenty of highs
to tip the scale. "Stumble On," "World's Eye View," and "Cat Scan" are all
well-executed, breezy tunes that hint at a really great future for Novillero.
But you know what they say about those damned Winnipegians: they never can get
it right the first time.
-Matt LeMay