Eric Mingus
Um... Er... Uh...
[Some]
Rating: 7.3
I have a friend that's compiled a list of songs that remind her of being
in Pier One Imports. Somewhere on that list, among the inevitable Police
and Simply Red tracks, is Julian Lennon's "Too Late for Goodbyes." Poor
kid: his father changed rock music forever, and he's just a guy who reminds
a friend of mine of some whitebread home decor chain.
This is not to say that I think Julian Lennon's music is due for a
re-evaluation. But you have to feel for these kids-- the progeny of
musical icons who, for whatever reason, follow in their famous parents'
footsteps. I mean, what a crappy way to start a career: defending your
work against insane expectations as soon as your first album hits the
shelves. Julian probably would've been better off as a dentist, you
know, but I'm sure he never felt like he had much of a choice-- raised
famous, expected to take over his father's business, and destined to
fail. Or at least to achieve a level of success that seems like failure
in light of his genealogy.
So, here's Eric Mingus, whose father arguably did for jazz much of what
John Lennon did for rock, making a decidedly ill-advised move and releasing
an album. What's worse, it's basically a jazz record. And crazier still,
the stupid kid goes and plays double-bass on it. Which is just plain
asking for it, really.
But he seems to have lucked out in a couple of ways. First of all, a lot
of the reviews of Um... Er... Uh... thus far have been written by
people largely unaware of just how monumental a figure Charles Mingus
was. This is totally out of Eric's control, of course, but it's a dodged
bullet nonetheless. More importantly, though, he seems to have actually
inherited some of his dad's talent, and to have spent a good deal of time
and energy developing it. And somebody in his ancestry left him with the
voice of a wayward Baptist preacher: gritty but smooth, soulful but somehow
lascivious.
Um... Er... Uh... seems like a pretty straightforward record. Most
songs feature a traditional unit of drums, bass, sax and trumpet, with Mingus
singing or speaking. The overall feel is loose and improvisational, but
rooted in well-charted territory. There's jazz here for sure, but there's
also R&B;, acid jazz and gospel. Plus, Eric seems to share his father's
penchant for taking vernacular forms and giving them an avant-garde twist.
"Romantic Fool," for example, is a straight-up soul slow jam which happens
to feature a bass solo that's been so electronically altered that the
instrument sounds like a bizarre kazoo. The contributions of electronic
artist Mocean Worker help rough things up a little as well, and give the
album some unexpected textures.
Mingus' lyrics occasionally grate, falling into the sort of preachy sing-song
that mars so much spoken word. But for every cringe, there are enough
surprising turns of phrase to balance things out. The excellent "His Blood's
in Me"-- set to some Tom Waits-esque noise-mongering-- avoids all the pitfalls
and manages to be confrontational and melancholy without becoming ridiculous.
"Grey... Was Never So Color... Full..." is what all unaccompanied spoken word
should be: rhythmic and inventive, with no trace of college-town coffee house
goofiness.
But does Eric live up to his father's standards? Well, of course not. Charles
Mingus recorded over a hundred albums, wrote something like 300 original
compositions, and played sideman to the greatest jazz musicians the world is
likely to ever see. It's crazy to judge this album by those standards. Eric's
off to a good start, though. And at the very least, Um... Er... Uh...
will never remind anybody of a trip to Pier One.
-Zach Hooker